Mahvash Ikram
When questions arise about whether an elderly person really understood the decisions they were making when they drafted their will, courts may turn to a key witness: the lawyer who drafted the document.
Speaking at a recent legal conference, special counsel Bethan Read said recent case law suggests judges may place greater weight on a lawyer’s contemporaneous observations of a client’s state of mind than on expert opinions formed after the client’s death.
“The courts give significant weight to our [lawyers’] evidence, and they’ve made it clear they won’t easily overturn the view of an experienced lawyer,” Read told attendees at The Law Association of New Zealand’s (TLANZ) Cradle to Grave conference.
Recent case law suggests judges often favour the views of lawyers who assessed their client’s mental capacity at the time a will was drafted over expert opinions based on records and second-hand observations made after the will-maker’s death, Read said.
In the 2024 High Court case of the Estate of Spellers, Justice Ian Gault said although the deceased was suffering from dementia when he made his will in 2015, based on the evidence from his lawyer and physicians, his mental capacity at the time could not be challenged – despite retrospective opinion to the contrary.
“The court, preferred the evidence of the lawyer who made the will and… the court commented that ‘the 2015 will was professionally prepared by an experienced independent lawyer who formed the view that despite his dementia diagnosis, Mr. Spellers had capacity, which the court should not readily overturn, particularly on the basis of expert evidence where the expert did not meet the will maker,” Read said.
For this reason, good record-keeping and detailed file notes of interactions with the will-maker are essential – especially when it comes to dealing with elderly clients, Read said.
“Their instructions give us a good idea [if] there’s going to be a claim under the Family Protection Act or similar on their death… we [lawyers] might be the main person responsible for assessing whether our clients have capacity to make a will.”
The “golden rule” in case of any concerns about mental fitness was for the lawyer to advise getting a capacity assessment, but that was not always possible.
“Sometimes clients [may] simply refuse to get one and what we’re seeing at the moment is it can take quite a lot of time to get an appointment with some of the high-level specialists … we just simply can’t afford to wait in that situation.”
In such instances the lawyer’s duty is to prepare the will and make sure it’s signed, leaving issues of capacity to be determined after the client’s death.
However, Read said, that did not mean that the lawyer’s job ended there.
“Quite the opposite. Our rule is crucial here because we are potentially going to be the only person able to assess capacity… because if a claim is made on the grounds of incapacity, the courts are going to look in detail at our evidence.”
‘Red flags’ and small talk
Lawyers should also engage in “small talk” with their client when the will is being discussed, as it’s a useful way of determining if there had been undue influence.
“We’re going to be in a key position to pick up any red flags or the involvement of third parties… [for example] a client uplifting their file and instructing us on a will, when they’ve had a lawyer who’s acted them for many years.”
Read’s “key tips” were to meet the client alone, ask probing questions, and to make sure the client understood the consequences of making any changes to their will.
“I’ve had situations where clients have notes in front of them, they’ve been clearly prepped by someone… what I do in that situation is deviate immediately from the notes and the usual questions and try small talk to get some of the information in my probing questions.”
These casual conversations also proved crucial in determining mental capacity. Things to look out for include the client’s ability to recall the lawyer’s name or the date.
“I’ve had a capacity issue where someone has not remembered my name despite significant ongoing communications with them. And often, that that kind of small talk can also be quite important in an undue influence context.”
Documenting these casual conversations could prove useful if a dispute were to arise after the client’s death.
It was important to tailor advice to the client and present it to them in a way they understood best.
“Sometimes clients don’t like to be talked at, but actually like to see things up [visually]… so grab a whiteboard and put things up,” she said.
Urgent wills
When a will was required urgently, there was always the possibility it may not be completed in time.
“In that situation, as well as rushing around trying to get to the final line, we also need to have one eye on the possibility we don’t get there and set up our files to preempt a validation claim,” Read said.
Under s 14 of the Wills Act 2007, the High Court can validate a document that does not meet the requirements of a will – however, the courts have made it clear that this is a restorative stance, Read said.. In such instances, the court relied on file notes, digital and handwritten records, audio transcripts of meetings and will questionnaires.
“Your file notes should be so much more detailed than normal.” The court could only validate what was in the document.
“If you’re missing any ancillary clauses, or you forget the ifs and buts clauses, they’re not going to be implied by the court.”

0 Comments