Equity – trust law – fiduciary duties – appeal by trustees of High Court decision that granted adult children’s claim against a trust settled by their father – disputed disposition to trust – “unwinding” the disposition to the trust – applicable principles – procedure – whether fiduciary duties owed by parent to child – whether breach of fiduciary duties – abusive childhood and family life – whether constructive trust – Family Protection Act 1955 – precedent – appeal by trustees allowed; no fiduciary duty held by father at time of disputed disposition (majority decision)
D and E Limited as trustees of the Z Trust v A, B and C [2022] NZCA 430 (Kós P, Gilbert and Collins JJ)
This Court of Appeal decision considers several legal issues surrounding a father’s (R’s) transfer of much of his assets to a trust of which his four children were not beneficiaries [one adult child had earlier passed away, and his estate was not involved in these proceedings].
R’s transfer of his assets to a trust and his failure to provide for his children in his will meant that when R died, his children were effectively prevented from inheriting from his estate or from making a meaningful Family Protection Act 1955 claim unless the property transferred to the trust reverted to R’s personal estate.
All three of R’s surviving children claimed R had been abusive to them, with R’s daughter A in particular suffering significant ongoing health, emotional and personal issues from the “egregious”, serious and long-term sexual abuse she had endured as a young child.
R had denied the abuse when confronted about it during his lifetime. However, the High Court found R’s children to have given evidence “honestly and accurately” about the abuse each of them had suffered and when A was an adult, her situation had been accepted for ACC cover by the ACC Sensitive Claims Unit.
R’s previous wills demonstrated he had provided for all his children to some degree in those earlier wills, although his last will did not include his children as beneficiaries.
R’s children claimed that he owed them fiduciary duties as their father and that he had breached those duties by his abuse of them and by his transfer of his assets to the trust to prevent his children making a meaningful claim under the Family Protection Act 1955.
R’s children also claimed those fiduciary duties were visited upon the surviving trustees. R’s children were successful in their claims in the High Court where the court held [in summary] that at the time of the disposition to the trust, the relationship between R and his children carried particular fiduciary obligations and that the assets held by the trust were held on constructive trust for R’s children. The surviving trustees of the trust now appeal that High Court decision to the Court of Appeal.
Applicable principles – extensive analysis and review of the legal options available to R’s children (the eldest of whom was born in 1960 and the youngest in 1971) including discussion of the family dynamics, the advent of the Accident Compensation Act 1972 (which came into force in 1974) and the civil claims available to persons prior to that time, the understandable reasons why criminal complaints may not have been pursued and the position of children as adults, including comprehensive discussion by all three learned Judges of the concept, existence and extent of fiduciary duties within the family unit and more generally – detailed consideration of the scope of fiduciary duties with wide-ranging extensive reference to case law, both in New Zealand and overseas – “trust and confidence” – characteristics of a fiduciary relationship – extent of distinction between young children and adult children and the nature of the fiduciary relationship
Held: the trustees’ appeal is allowed; there was no fiduciary duty held by R towards his children at time of the disputed disposition of property to the trust (majority decision; Collins J dissented; see paras 1-119 of the decision for dissenting judgment).
Sacha Jugum is a senior solicitor at Brookfields and editor of The Bulletin.
0 Comments