The Law Association’s Employment Law Committee has submitted on MBIE’s consultation on the employment dispute system, calling for practical reform of how disputes move through the system rather than a full structural replacement of the institutions that manage them.
The submission’s central position is that mediation, the Employment Relations Authority and the Employment Court each have value and should be retained. It is noted that the problem is not the existence of those stages, but what happens between them: poor routing, procedural duplication, outdated administration and the absence of a reliable evidential record in the Authority.
The Committee points out that on current performance; the numbers speak for themselves. In 2025/26 year-to-date data, mediation takes around 36.6 working days and an Authority matter around 203 working days. A dispute passing through all stages can take approximately two years.
The Committee’s most significant recommendations begin with discontinuing Early Resolution. The service is described as information-poor, unclear in status and duplicative of mediation. It concluded that resources would be better redirected to a service with proper statutory standing and trained mediators capable of completing enforceable settlements.
The submission is clear that mediation itself should remain free. The Committee argues that direct user charges would push more disputes into the Authority and the Court, where costs to both parties and the public are significantly higher. Alongside that, it calls on MBIE to implement an efficiency package the Committee previously provided, covering online booking, urgency triage, better pre-mediation preparation and greater access to in-person mediation for cases where it is likely to produce a better result.
The submission identifies the absence of an official record of Authority proceedings as a serious and fundamental flaw. Evidence given under oath in the Authority is currently not recorded, meaning witnesses can materially change their account at a later challenge without any reliable means of testing what they said earlier. The Committee recommends audio recording of all substantive investigation meetings, with secure transcription available when a matter is challenged.
On challenge procedure, the Committee recommends MBIE consult on a model under section 179 in which the Court receives the Authority record and exercises discretion over whether evidence is reheard in full, in part or not at all. The Court would retain power to conduct a full evidential hearing where justice requires it, but a challenge could not be used simply as a better-prepared second attempt.
On administration, the submission calls for structured digital forms, proportionate length limits and basic registry screening across all filings. It also proposes that, over time, the Authority pilot AI-assisted initial screening of filings, particularly those filed by self-represented parties, to identify missing information, excessive length or an unintelligible claim before the matter progresses.
In terms of court access, the Committee recommends reviewing section 178 of the Employment Relations Act to allow suitable matters, particularly those that are complex, expert-heavy or precedent-setting, to proceed directly to the Employment Court without an extended preliminary contest in the Authority.
The submission also supports proportionate regulation of paid employment advocates and calls for investment in modern digital case management, including electronic filing and Authority-administered case books. The Committee clarified that it has not yet endorsed a settled model for regulating advocates.
Click here to read The Law Association’s submission on the Review of the Employment Dispute System.
0 Comments