A submission by The Law Association of New Zealand on proposed changes to trespass laws warns the bill could criminalise low-level conduct and impose disproportionate penalties on vulnerable people.
The Trespass (Specified Retail Premises and Other Matters) Amendment Bill allows retailers and other businesses to issue warnings that ban individuals from multiple locations for up to three years. Breach of a warning can result in criminal prosecution.The Law Association’s Criminal Law Committee recognises the seriousness of retail crime and the need to protect workers and businesses. However, the submission warns that the bill expands criminal liability without sufficient safeguards.
Under the proposed law, a single incident at one store could result in exclusion from numerous unrelated locations. A person who enters any covered premises during the ban period commits an offence, even if they were unaware that location was included in the original warning.
The submission says this risks disconnecting criminal consequences from the original conduct. It is particularly concerning where the person never attended, or never intended to attend, the additional locations.
The bill introduces a provision that a person may be deemed to have received a warning if they refuse to accept it or if they “ought to have known” it was being given. The committee says this lowers the knowledge threshold and moves the regime toward negligence-based liability in an area that can result in criminal prosecution.
The submission argues that the knowledge requirement is not a technicality. It ensures a person has the information needed to avoid committing an offence. That is especially important in retail environments, where the public ordinarily expects to be able to enter shops and other commercial spaces unless clearly told otherwise.
The committee is concerned that the deeming provision may generate disputes about whether a person understood what was being said or ought to have known that a warning was being given. These disputes are likely to increase litigation over the validity and effect of notices.
The bill permits occupiers, including groups of occupiers, to issue trespass notices and delegate that power to others. The submission warns that private individuals and businesses may effectively exercise quasi-public enforcement powers, with breach of those privately issued warnings giving rise to criminal liability.
The submission argues that where private decisions can trigger criminal liability, the statutory framework should be clear, constrained and procedurally fair. The bill should ensure that decision-makers are identifiable, that the basis and scope of the warning are clear, and that affected individuals have practical information about how to avoid breach.
The submission also raises concerns about disproportionate impact on vulnerable groups, including homeless people, young people, Māori and people experiencing mental health issues. Broad multi-location bans may restrict access to essential services, particularly where large retail chains control access to everyday goods in a local area.
The bill increases maximum fines to $2,000 and $1,000 for relevant conduct. The submission says it is concerning that those increases are not matched by stronger procedural protections.
If the bill proceeds, the committee recommends amendments to ensure warnings are clear, necessary, proportionate, properly recorded and capable of review or revocation. Safeguards should guard against selective, arbitrary, discriminatory or disproportionate use.
0 Comments