Neil Sands
The value-based pricing model facilitated by artificial intelligence (AI) requires a fundamental mindshift from the deeply ingrained practice of billable hours, and not all lawyers will be able to ‘turn off the clock’ in their brain, the LawFest conference in Auckland was told on Thursday.
Tessa van Duyn
Tessa van Duyn, the chief executive and practice manager at Melbourne law firm Moores, said some of her colleagues departed when value-based pricing was introduced because they struggled to stop viewing all aspects of their work in billable increments of six-minutes.
Those that remained, she said, had benefitted from a system that prioritises outcomes over clock-watching, fostering deeper relationships with clients and allowing greater workplace flexibility and wellbeing for her firm’s lawyers.
Crucially, van Duyn said Moores’ bottom line had remained robust since it introduced value-based charging around a decade ago, increased revenue and profitability.
She said time-based charging made little sense when AI could complete work in five minutes that used to take three hours and generate charges of $1,000.
Instead, van Duyn said Moores dealt in achieving outcomes for its clients, offering them several options, ranging from ‘Rolls-Royce’ service catering to all their goals and needs, to a more basic “Toyota Corolla” offering.
“It really puts the client at the heart of your business,” she said. “You’re handing choice to a client in terms of how they want to pay for something, what it is they’re after. They can be quite specific about the outcome of a product that they’re after, or the particular service, and what price they pay.
“It [the relationship] is upfront. It shifts the dynamic a little bit in the relationship, I’d say for the better. There’s transparency for the client in terms of price and the outcome that you’re promising. That gives them more agency, as well as price certainty. It builds trust, which ultimately is the greatest currency.”
‘Tricky’ transition
Van Duyn admitted some clients – and lawyers – were uncomfortable when Moores introduced its new pricing model and could not make the change.
“I’ll be really honest and say that the first few years of our transition to value-based pricing was challenging,” she said. “We lost clients who couldn’t wrap their head around it. In particular, a number of them couldn’t understand how to compare an apple, which was us, to an orange – a time-based billing law firm. That was a tricky hurdle to get over.
“The other thing that we lost was some of our people who had been with Moores for so long that they were deeply entrenched in the concept of working and ascribing your value to six-minute units. They couldn’t unshackle themselves from that.”
In addition to client benefits, van Duyn said lawyers who were open to new ways of working enjoyed a more collaborative environment where they were not chained to a desk for 10 hours-a-day in order to justify billing for seven hours.
“What we find, particularly with lateral hires, like me when I was coming from Big Law, is the unlearning that’s required to shift the mindset to the outcome that you’ve created for somebody… as compared to how long that’s taken me to do something. It really does require a particular culture [shift] I would say, and it means we have to turn that clock off.”

0 Comments