By LawNews Staff
The Law Association of New Zealand has launched a comprehensive Property Disputes Committee Rulings Manual containing details of more than 80 disputes over a 35-year period.
The manual gives lawyers a practical reference guide to rulings on property conflicts – from complicated rows over settlement to whether a removable flagpole on a property’s lawn counts as a fixture or chattel.
Tina Hwang, convenor of The Law Association’s Property Law Committee, said the document draws on decades of real-world dispute resolution experience.
“These rulings show what issues come up repeatedly in property practice. Cross-lease disputes, commercial lease disputes (often on liability for costs of repairs), settlement compensation claims, disputes to settlement and penalty interests, contractual interpretations, vacant possession issues, breach of vendor warranties and undertaking issues. These are the same disputes surfacing again and again,” Hwang said.
In an area where the devil’s often in the detail, the manual covers 20 categories of disputes, giving particulars about conflicts involving apportionments, cross-leases, deposit issues, lease disputes, settlement complications, undertakings, unit title matters, stakeholder disputes and misdescription claims.
Rulings date from 1986 to 2020 and include contextual notes updating references to the Agreement for Sale and Purchase of Real Estate (ASPRE) and ADLS lease provisions where forms or legislation have changed.
It was launched on Thursday at a conference on property disputes hosted by The Law Association which examined issues including an increase in lease disputes, investment property conflicts and how dispute resolution mechanisms are working in the current economic environment.
The Law Association’s President Tony Herring said the manual and conference reflect his organisation’s commitment to helping practitioners navigate property disputes efficiently.
“The Property Disputes Committee provides binding rulings on the papers through 14 volunteer specialist lawyers. It’s a cost-effective alternative dispute resolution mechanism. The manual makes 35 years of that experience accessible,” Herring said.
“The conference examined where the pressure points are now. We’re seeing more complex investment property structures, clause 10 compensation claims that don’t deliver the resolution they promise and cross-lease disputes that could have been prevented with better upfront advice.” he added.
The Law Association’s Property Disputes Committee Rulings Manual is available to download here – The-Law-Association-of-New-Zealand-Property-Disputes-Committee-Rulings-Manual

0 Comments