The bill creates some sweeping obligations on businesses without giving much guidance around how businesses are expected to comply
The Privacy Amendment Bill currently before Parliament proposes to create a new obligation on businesses, requiring them to take reasonable steps to notify individuals when their personal information is collected via third parties, or indirectly.
The bill creates a new Information Privacy Principle 3A (IPP3A) to supplement the existing IPP3 in the Privacy Act 2020.
IPP3A is primarily modelled on the current IPP3 which deals with the direct collection of personal information.
The stated aim of the bill is to improve transparency for individuals about the collection of their personal information and to better enable individuals to exercise their privacy rights.
Indirect collection
While there is an obligation on businesses to tell individuals when they are directly collecting their information and that they are passing the information to third parties, there is no obligation for businesses to tell individuals which third parties they are passing it to.
Therefore, there is often no way for individuals to know which third parties hold their information after the initial collection. In practice this means people can easily lose track of who has their information and for what purpose. The bill is trying to close this loophole.
Such a change will more closely align New Zealand’s Privacy Act with international privacy standards, including those of the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and Australia’s Privacy Act 1988.
But further changes in addition to this bill would be required to reach the stringent levels of transparency and consumer trust facilitated by these frameworks.
Arguably, this loophole requires attention to better protect individuals and it is positive that New Zealand wants to further align with international privacy standards, but it is questionable whether the current bill will create any further protection for consumers in a practical sense.
A blunt instrument
The bill creates some sweeping obligations on businesses without giving much guidance around how businesses are expected to comply.
For example, the bill does not contain any practical guidance on how businesses are meant to notify consumers that their personal information has been collected indirectly or passed on to a third party.
Methods currently used, such as privacy statements and email notifications, may not always be practical when working with very large data sets or when the personal information does not include contact details.
The bill does introduce one notable exemption: organisations will not be required to comply with the notification requirement where the individual concerned has previously been made aware of the fact their information has been indirectly collected or passed on to a third party, for example, by the original business that first collected the personal information.
In practice, this exemption may lead to privacy statements (which currently deal with direct collection of information) containing longwinded lists of all the third parties to whom information may be disclosed by the business conducting the original collection.
On this exemption, the bill provides the following example:
An agency (A) has collected personal information from the individual concerned. A has disclosed the information to another agency (B). B, after collecting the information, is not required to comply with subclause (1) [ie, the notification requirements under IPP 3A] if A, when complying with IPP 3, notified the individual concerned that the information would be disclosed to B and of the matters in subclause (1) in relation to B’s collection of the information.
The section does not clarify the extent of disclosure required by party A for this purpose, and whether a general statement about certain categories of recipients is sufficient, or if specific identification of recipients is required.
As it may not be feasible to name all individual recipients of the information, the ability to disclose categories/classes of information recipients to suffice for compliance with the notification requirement is important.
There is a lack of explicit guidance on this issue, presenting an opportunity to align with international best practices such as Articles 13 and 14 of the GDPR.
Compliance costs
The introduction of additional notification requirements on businesses, whether through channels such as text and email or via detailed privacy statements, will inevitably escalate the compliance burden and may lead to higher costs of doing business.
Such developments are likely to stimulate the growth of a specialised sector focused on aiding businesses with compliance tasks, effectively creating a cottage industry of privacy compliance professionals.
In an economic climate marked by rising inflation and heightened concerns about the cost of living, these increased business expenses are likely to be passed on to consumers.
Consequently, while the intent to strengthen privacy protection is commendable, the practical implications could pose significant economic challenges.
Additionally, there is a question about the extent to which the availability of further information leads to increased engagement by consumers.
There is a significant risk that the proliferation of privacy-related notifications – whether through lengthy privacy statements or direct communications such as emails or texts – could lead to widespread notification fatigue among the public.
As recipients are bombarded with an increasing volume of informational alerts, their ability to maintain attention and engagement may diminish significantly.
This reduces the likelihood that individuals will read, understand or act on the information provided, thereby diluting the efficacy of such notifications.
When critical alerts about data usage and rights blend into a constant stream of updates, the intended effect of raising awareness is lost.
The challenge, therefore, lies in designing notification systems that capture attention without overwhelming, thus maintaining their effectiveness in safeguarding consumer privacy and enhancing data-protection awareness.
Penalties
Another approach to ensuring greater privacy protection for individuals could involve enhancing the incentive structure for businesses to comply with the current Privacy Act and dramatically increasing penalties in line with international standards.
For example, under the EU’s GDPR, penalties for noncompliance can reach up to 4% of an organisation’s annual global turnover, or €20 million, whichever is higher, creating a substantial deterrent against privacy violations.
Similarly, Australia has recently revised its Privacy Act to impose penalties that can extend into the tens of millions of dollars, reflecting a global trend towards stricter enforcement measures that truly incentivise companies to prioritise privacy.
The penalties under our Act sit at $10,000 per breach, which is relatively low by international standards.
This reduces the urgency for businesses to establish costly privacy compliance programs.
Consequently, many businesses may perceive potential privacy breach penalties as merely another cost of doing business, rather than a significant risk to be mitigated.
By aligning our penalty structure with those seen in jurisdictions like the EU or Australia, we could shift this perception, promoting a more compliance-oriented business environment.
This would not only enhance consumer trust but also ensure businesses take their obligations under the Privacy Act seriously, leading to better protection of individual privacy rights and alignment with international best practices in privacy enforcement.
Key takeaways
The stated aim of the bill is to improve transparency for individuals about the collection of their personal information, better enabling them to exercise their privacy rights.
By creating further transparency, it is hoped this will create further engagement on the part of individuals, enabling and encouraging them to make proactive decisions about how their personal information is used.
But will more transparency lead to greater engagement by individuals?
At a time when people are constantly connected to the internet and everyone has dozens of apps on their phone, is it realistic to put the burden of making proactive decisions about storage and use of personal information on individuals?
Is it realistic to expect individuals to be sufficiently engaged to make such decisions, let alone have the knowledge and expertise to understand the choices they make?
Perhaps leaving such decisions in the hands of individuals is not the solution and a wider lens is required when determining where choices around appropriate use of personal information ultimately rest.
Amy Kingston-Turner is a director at Source Legal NZ and a member of The Law Association’s Technology and Law committee.
0 Comments