Chris Trotter
There was a time in our history when elections had the power to change things.
Not just in a small way, but in ways that would continue to shape New Zealand society for decades. Changes so significant that their implacable opponents were eventually forced to make their peace with them. A case of either accepting the new order, or losing any hope of ever again winning a general election.
The most dramatic example of the power of the electorate to cement in place what had initially been viewed as a fragile and highly controversial set of reforms is the general election of 1938.
Two of the most controversial reforms – the introduction of compulsory union membership and the legislation establishing social security –represented the key building blocks of the new society which the first Labour government, in its first term (1935-1938), was beginning to construct.
“Applied lunacy!” thundered Sid Holland, easily the most forceful representative of the newly-formed National Party.
“Applied Christianity!” responded the mild-mannered Mickey Savage.
“Mickey” may have been mild-mannered, but he wasn’t stupid. He had passed the Social Security Act in 1938 but was careful to make sure it would not come into force until 1 April 1939.
If New Zealanders wanted to keep the new social order Labour was building, then they would have to vote for it. Because Adam Hamilton, Leader of the Opposition, had made it crystal clear that if National won, then the Social Security Act, along with just about all the other reforms Labour had introduced, would be swept away.
So, no pressure, New Zealand.
National’s was not the only voice raised in opposition to Labour’s legislation. New Zealand’s newspaper editors were united in their opposition to Labour’s plans. In not a few cases, press resistance bordered on the unhinged. This is what The Dominion had to say as Kiwis went to the polls on 15 October 1938:
“Today you will exercise a free vote because you are under this established British form of government. If the socialist government is returned to power, your vote today may be the last free individual vote you will ever be given the opportunity to exercise in New Zealand.”
So, maybe a little bit of pressure.
By the end of the day, however, New Zealanders had delivered the most decisive electoral verdict in this country’s political history. Labour captured 55.8% of the popular vote, an improvement of more than 10 percentage points on its 1935 result.
Compulsory unionism would endure in New Zealand for the next 53 years. Though National made many promises to smash this crucial element of Labour’s new order, it was finally abolished only in 1991, six years after David Lange’s fourth Labour government had methodically deconstructed most of the institutions created by the first.
Social security, battered and bruised though it may be, is still with us.
Policy consensus
So, why is it that 88 years after the watershed election of 1938 it has become well-nigh impossible to assemble a parliamentary majority equal to the task of changing our own world as thoroughly as the men and women of the first Labour government changed theirs?
The answer would appear to be that the parties of today are no more capable of rolling back the changes of the 1980s and 90s than National was of reversing Labour’s reforms of the 1930s and 40s.
It is important to note here that the formation of coalition governments, which the introduction of MMP made practically mandatory, is not responsible for making radical change impossible. While all coalitions require compromises, they would not exist if the participating parties did not share a common commitment to, or at least a willingness to accept, the prevailing ‘commonsense’ about what constitute ‘realistic’ economic and social policies.
Parties like ACT and the Greens, which both favour reforms at least as all-encompassing as those of the 1930s and the 1980s, inevitably find themselves thrust up against the brick wall of ideological orthodoxy which National and Labour have jointly constructed to prevent any meaningful disruption of the prevailing policy consensus.
That is why National and Labour only ever allow their “partners” to order an entrée – never a main course.
Out of ideas
It requires something truly catastrophic – economic collapse, famine, pestilence, war, all of the above on a global scale – to shatter a consensus that strong. It also requires a political establishment that has run out of answers.
The first Labour government had answers equal to the urgent and defining questions of its time. In 1984, Lange and his Finance Minister, Roger Douglas, wagered Labour’s future on of a suite of radical economic and social policies that their Treasury advisers were assuring them would answer the questions of their own.
With the collapse of Soviet-style socialism in 1991, the Rogernomes’ mantra that there was no alternative to free-market capitalism seemed to have been vindicated.
More importantly, National in the 1990s proved to be no more capable of resisting the spirit of the times than it had been in the 1930s. ‘Ruthanasia’ succeeded ‘Rogernomics’, and half-a-century after the introduction of compulsory unionism National finally found itself in a position to slay the dragon of organised labour.
No longer convinced that it was on the right side of history, the trade union movement meekly succumbed to National’s blade.
Lying to the electorate
The Italian Marxist philosopher Antonio Gramsci (1891-1937) famously diagnosed the political paralysis of his own time in his Prison Notebooks:
“The crisis consists precisely in the fact that the old is dying and the new cannot be born; in this interregnum a great variety of morbid symptoms appear.”
Or, as Google’s AI assistant helpfully explains:
“Gramsci was describing a ‘crisis of authority’ or a structural deadlock. It refers to an unstable transitional period (an interregnum) where an old sociopolitical order or ideology is collapsing, but the new alternative has not yet gained the strength to take its place, leading to destructive and bizarre political symptoms.”
Among the most frustrating of these “destructive and bizarre political symptoms”, from the point of view of the New Zealand voter, is that practically every party with a reasonable chance of being seated in the House of Representatives finds itself more-or-less obliged to lie to the electorate.
Ever since the Global Financial Crisis of 2008-09, the neoliberal ideology which drove the huge changes of the 1980s and 90s has ceased to function as a reliable policy pathfinder. This would not have morphed into the colossal political and cultural problem it has now become if a persuasive and implementable substitute had presented itself to political leaders around the world.
Very few politicians outside of the USA, Brazil, and Argentina are convinced that the transgressive disruptions perfected by Donald Trump, Jair Bolsonaro and Javier Milei offer anything approaching an enduring solution. Indeed, attempting to ape Trump and his MAGA movement in Australia and New Zealand is a massive vote-loser – as Peter Dutton discovered in 2025.
National and ACT cannot go there without precipitating a similarly fatal poll collapse. NZ First has tried, and been forced to scurry back onto safer ground when its efforts to mimic MAGA populism have been met with disappointment, disgruntlement and even threats of defection from Winston Peters’ most loyal supporters.
The dilemma is no less acute for the centre left. Neoliberalism may be fatally wounded, but its opposition to increasing taxes, re-nationalising privatised industries, reinvigorating the trade union movement and taking practical steps to address environmental despoilation and climate change, remains unflinching.
Reality has yet to shift Overton’s Window far enough to persuade Chris Hipkins and Barbara Edmonds that abandoning the economic prescriptions of neoliberalism will generate anything other than disparagement and derision from business and media elites – not to mention alarming its own economically orthodox followers.
Pointing to the success of New York mayor Zohran Mamdani offers no practical solace to the New Zealand Left. The victories racked-up by the democratic socialists of America are almost entirely attributable to the US practice of holding primary elections.
Social-democratic rhetoric reminiscent of Labour’s glory days is as far as Chippy is prepared to go. Rather than watching Mamdani, he will be following the evolution of UK Labour’s Andy Burnham. Declaring neoliberalism a 40-year failure is one thing. Presenting a genuinely social-democratic Budget, in defiance of the bond markets, is something else altogether.
The Greens and Opportunity are equally hamstrung by the political system’s inability to go either forward or back. Both parties have advanced a swathe of radical economic and social policies, insisting that they are essential, rational and applicable in the New Zealand context.
Unfortunately for them – if not their critics – the electorate is pretty sure that, in their heart of hearts, neither Chloe Swarbrick nor Qiulae Wong believes this to be true.
Electorate immobilised
As the 1News-Verian poll released earlier this week (13/10/26) confirmed, New Zealand politics is stuck.
Curiously, it is Te Pāti Māori which may yet find itself with a great deal more room to manoeuvre than the Pakeha parties. Its kaupapa is not limited by the same cultural and economic expectations currently immobilising its electoral competitors.
Many of Te Pāti Māori’s policies are dictated by the needs of communities operating well outside the free market system. For many Pakeha politicians this will be seen as a fatal constraint. It is not – any more than the impoverished condition of working-class New Zealanders was a constraint upon the imaginations of the leaders of the Depression-era Labour Party.
When an existing economic system offers a political party’s followers no plausible way of accessing its benefits, then the most obvious course of action – the course that recommended itself to Michael Joseph Savage and his comrades in the early 1930s – is not to allow oneself to be mesmerised by systemic paralysis, but to recognise that if the existing order is dying, then perhaps we should let it expire.
Perhaps it is time for the future to be born.

Chris Trotter
Chris Trotter has more than 30 years’ experience as a political analyst and commentator and is the author of the Bowalley Road blog

0 Comments