Chris Trotter
It is difficult to observe the foreign and domestic disruption unleashed by President Donald Trump without thinking of Ancient Rome.
After all, the fall of the Roman republic was accomplished by a ruthless populist who had successfully mobilised its ordinary citizens against its overbearing elites. Are we witnessing a comparable transformation? Is the American republic becoming the American empire?
The idea is getting harder and harder to shake.
But, let’s not panic. At least, not yet. Between them, Julius Caesar and his adopted heir, Octavian, may have buried the Roman republic but it had been brutally assaulted and grievously wounded many times before the Caesars finally killed it.
And even then, it was not immediately obvious to the ordinary Roman citizen that the old order had expired. All the offices of the republic remained in existence. The Senate continued to meet. Sacrifices to the gods were still overseen by the Pontifex Maximus. Octavian, now known as Augustus, didn’t even call himself “Imperator” (Emperor) preferring the more seemly republican title of “Princeps” (First Citizen).
Personal rule
But that is the way democracies die: slowly, almost imperceptibly, as all the institutions created to protect the rights of the citizen (and Ancient Rome had many) are emptied of their political autonomy and absorbed into the capricious processes of personal rule.
While the evidence that President Trump has set such processes in motion is irrefutable, the traducing of the American Constitution will be no simple matter. Especially when, unlike Rome, the United States’ political system has not been tested to destruction by decades of bloody internecine strife.
A sequence of fiercely-fought elections, conducted in circumstances of extreme polarisation, and exacerbated by wildly irresponsible propaganda, have certainly inflicted a large measure of damage on American society – but nothing like as much as civil war. The United States of America in 2025AD is in nothing like as much trouble as the Roman republic of 44BC.
In no small measure this is due to nearly all the founders of the United States being classically educated gentlemen, thoroughly familiar with the fate of the Roman republic. In drawing up their own republic’s constitution, they were careful to ring it round with a host of prophylactic checks and balances.
Perhaps anticipating the determination of some future American Caesar to make the Constitution more conducive to the imposition of personal rule, its authors made the document extremely difficult to alter.
Assuming that the future American Caesar and President Donald Trump are one and the same person, which part of the US Constitution would he be most anxious to change? Almost certainly, he would seek to repeal the 22nd Amendment, which reads:
“No person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice.”
To be fair to the original authors of the Constitution, that provision was a rather late addition to the document. Ratified in 1951, its purpose was to prevent future American politicians from following in the footsteps of Franklin D Roosevelt, who stood for the office of President – and was duly elected by the American people – four times in a row.
The 22nd Amendment was a Republican initiative which the party set in motion in 1947 by securing the support of two-thirds of the members of both the House of Representatives and the Senate.
That so many Democrats joined them in limiting future presidents to two terms was partly in recognition of the fact that prior to FDR, no other president had dared to seek a third term (let alone a fourth) and partly to make damn sure that no Democratic leader ever again kept so many of his party’s presidential hopefuls waiting for so long.
Even with Democratic Party support, the process of securing the 22nd Amendment’s endorsement by three-quarters of the state legislatures took four years. Changing the United States Constitution ain’t easy – and it sure as hell ain’t quick!
The workaround
Short of simply tearing up the Constitution and, in the finest tradition of his South American counterparts, instituting personal rule with the backing of the armed forces, is there any other way President Trump could make himself eligible for a third presidential term?
Not while the House and the Senate remain so evenly divided between Republicans and Democrats.
Certainly, there is absolutely no possibility that the present Democratic Party would vote to repeal of the 22nd Amendment. To secure the requisite two-thirds majority of both houses of Congress, therefore, some way would have to be found to make a large number of the Democratic Party representatives and senators disappear.
And that might just be possible if the states dominated electorally by the Democratic Party could somehow be goaded into openly resisting the policies of the federal government.
Declared at that point to be in rebellion against the United States, a move requiring no more than a simple majority in both houses, the representatives and senators of the resisting states might then, following the precedents laid down in the first 18 months of the American Civil War (1861-1865), find themselves expelled from the both houses of Congress.
A trigger point
What might the Trump administration do to provoke such open defiance and active resistance from America’s “blue” states? A federal abortion ban? The rounding-up and incarceration of tens of thousands of illegal immigrants in “special facilities”?
That might do the trick.
It would take only one or two governors to order their states’ National Guard to protect abortion clinics or release illegally detained citizens from federal custody for the resulting confrontation to explode into violence. Were that to happen, it is difficult to imagine President Trump not requiring his new, hand-picked Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff to enforce an executive order declaring martial law.
Yes, the President’s executive order would be challenged all the way to the Supreme Court. But when the appeal was laid before the conservative jurists assembled on that august bench, what would they do?
Defend the Constitution? Or confer even more executive authority on the President who made their majority? Recent precedent strongly suggests they would opt for the latter.
Another option
Is there an alternative path?
Because the US Constitution was written in the aftermath of revolution and war, there has always been the whiff of insurrectionary gunpowder about it. That scent of popular revolt is nowhere more evident than in the document’s splendid preamble:
“We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.”
Not quite so stirring but equally pregnant with political possibilities is Article V which sets out the manner in which the Constitution may be amended.
As alluded to above, the first option available – and, to date, the only option ever taken up – is to initiate the process by securing a two-thirds majority in both the House and the Senate, and then to have the proposed amendment ratified by three-quarters of the states.
The second option is much more radical. It states that Congress, “on the application of the legislatures of two-thirds of the several states, shall call a convention for proposing amendments”.
A convention? That would be a gathering of persons selected by each of the 50 states for the sole purpose of amending the Constitution.
While constitutional conventions have been proposed many times in the 235 years of US history, none (apart from the convention that convened in Philadelphia in 1787 to draft the original Constitution) has ever been called.
Why? The reason is obvious. Any such body would immediately cast all the other branches of government – the judiciary, the legislature, the executive – into its shade. Its deliberations, its decisions, would become all-important.
It would possess the power to reconfigure the relationship between the United States government and the people it purports to represent. In a single word, such a body would be revolutionary.
Doubtless, in the febrile atmosphere in which the United States presently finds itself, the overwhelming majority of delegates attending that revolutionary convention would arrive wearing MAGA caps.
Could this happen?
Until the 2026 mid-term congressional elections, 28 of the 50 states (59%) will continue to be controlled by the Republican Party. That’s just five states shy of the two-thirds required to convene a convention.
But, if six or seven blue states were declared to be in rebellion, then the Republican Party would find itself in a position to fundamentally change the US Constitution.
Impossible? Not at all. Indeed, Republicans have serious historical form when it comes to fundamentally changing the US Constitution. Once again, their political boldness was made possible by the constitutional gaps opened up by the Civil War.
To secure the emancipation and enfranchisement of African-Americans in the mid-1860s, it simply wasn’t necessary to summon a convention. By seceding from the Union (an act of rebellion) the representatives and senators of the Southern states had removed themselves, or been removed, from the deliberations of Congress.
The constitutional amendments giving effect to the abolition of slavery and granting African-Americans the “equal protection of the laws” were delivered by two-thirds majorities in Congress and ratified by three-quarters of the states remaining loyal to the Union, for the very simple reason that the Republican Party controlled both.
Mind you, the name of the Republican occupying the White House for the duration of that bloody civil conflict wasn’t Donald Trump, it was Abraham Lincoln – a political leader who would have been as honoured in the Roman republic as he still is in the American.
Chris Trotter has more than 30 years’ experience as a political writer and commentator. He is the author of the Bowalley Road blog

0 Comments