Sacha Jugum
The parties have a substantive hearing scheduled for 2021 where Ngāti Whātua seeks declarations as to its rights and status over certain land in the Tāmaki Makaurau [Auckland] area.
The proceedings follow an earlier application for judicial review which was considered by the Supreme Court. Some aspects of the iwi’s original proceedings would have essentially meant a challenge to legislation, or that the court would be in a position of commenting on or impacting on the passage of legislation. This is within the ambit of Parliament, not the courts.
Ngāti Whātua also applied for declarations relating to the level of Crown consultation and the way in which the Crown’s overlapping claims policy should be implemented and observed.
Applicable principles – extensive discussion of procedure, including the inclusion and importance of tikanga and the jurisdiction of the court to reference tikanga and appoint relevant experts – consideration of whether there are factual disputes and whether these were disputes or only differences in expression – whether the existing witnesses would be sufficient – significance of cross-examination of witnesses – consideration of academic commentary and precedent – applicability of High Court Rules 2016 – analysis of the most appropriate way to hear and use the expert evidence of witnesses
Held: [after discussion of all matters] leave granted for cross-examination of certain witnesses, by consent – application to appoint pūkenga declined.
Read case at Judicial Decisions Online
0 Comments