Application for leave to bring a second appeal against sentence – Criminal Procedure Act 2011, s 253 – impact of imprisonment on appellant’s 11 children – application for leave to adduce new evidence (ongoing impact of incarceration on appellant’s children) – is the court satisfied that a miscarriage of justice may occur if the appeal is not heard?
Bagley v R [2024] NZCA 646
David Bagley is a 43 year old father of 11 children aged between 18 months and 17 years. He has more than 160 convictions, including for dishonesty and family violence offending.
In February 2024, Bagley was sentenced to two years and four months’ imprisonment on a number of charges, including wilful damage, threatening to kill, assault on a person in a family relationship and 11 charges of theft under $500.
The offending against his partner occurred in front of his children. It included threatening to stab her, pulling her by her ponytail off her feet and kicking her body and head while she was on the ground. The children were yelling at him to stop.
Bagley appealed his sentence to the High Court. The High Court allowed the appeal and reduced the sentence to two years and two months’ imprisonment, finding that an additional discount ought to have been given to reflect Bagley’s time in state care which it was accepted had causatively contributed to his history of offending.
In the High Court, Bagley raised a new matter – seeking a further discount to reflect the impact of his imprisonment on his children. This was not raised in the District Court, which had a victim impact statement from Bagley’s partner (signed by a police officer) referring to him contributing nothing to the family. The High Court declined to give any further discount.
Bagley sought leave to bring a second appeal against his sentence, on the basis that a discount for the impact of his imprisonment on his children should have been given.
He also sought leave to adduce new evidence in support of his application, namely an affidavit from his partner which provided an update as to the ongoing impact of his incarceration on their children.
The affidavit explained that Bagley had been moved to the Otago Corrections Facility, which is a five-hour drive away from where his partner and children live. This meant the children had not been able to visit him. His partner stated that they were missing their father deeply and she struggled to manage them without his support. This evidence was not before the High Court.
Applicable principles: Criminal Procedure Act 2011, s 253 – application of Lundy v R test for admissibility of new evidence on an appeal – is the new evidence credible? (yes) – is the new evidence fresh? (no, it could have been obtained at the time of the High Court appeal) – should the new evidence nevertheless be admitted? (yes, no prejudice to the Crown) – application of Philip v R approach to discount to reflect the effect imprisonment may have on offender’s children – is the court satisfied that a miscarriage of justice may occur unless the appeal is heard? (no, the High Court squarely addressed the issue of whether a discrete discount ought to be given for the impact of Bagley’s incarceration on his children. There is no evidence or material suggesting Bagley had played a primary or constant caregiving role in his children’s lives and nothing to suggest his present incarceration is having an undue impact on the interests of his children).
Held: The application for leave to adduce fresh evidence is granted. The application for leave to bring a second appeal against sentence is declined. The case falls well below the high threshold which would justify the court conducting a further review of Bagley’s sentence.
0 Comments