Mahvash Ikram
A senior practitioner was “grossly negligent” when he twice set up corporate structures designed to circumvent the consenting provisions of the Overseas Investment Act (OIA), a disciplinary tribunal has found.
The transactions were done on behalf of two offshore clients who wanted to buy large tracts of sensitive New Zealand forestry land, even though Andrew James Jarvis – a lawyer with 40 years’ experience – had little knowledge or understanding of the OIA.
His clients were keen to avoid paying the estimated $20,000 to $40,000 required for each transaction, had they gone through the formal OIA consenting process. Jarvis, their lawyer, thought he had stumbled upon a clever loophole in the law. He was wrong.
Jarvis was also unaware that his conduct breached his professional obligations, the Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal said in a decision released earlier this month. In fact, his actions displayed a very high level of negligence “that would shock members of the public”.
“That a competent lawyer could fail so dismally in matters of such importance to his clients satisfies the statutory test,” the tribunal said.
Further, it said the negligence was of such a degree that his conduct brought the profession into disrepute.
It was not the first time Jarvis had appeared in a judicial forum to answer for his wrongdoing.
In February 2025, he admitted breaches of s 43 of the OIA and was ordered to pay a civil pecuniary penalty of $275,000 after a hearing in the High Court at Auckland.
His subsequent appearance before the tribunal was the first disciplinary misstep in his career. Jarvis admitted a charge of unsatisfactory conduct but faced two further alternative charges of misconduct or negligence.
The tribunal was given details of the New Zealand-based companies he established on behalf of the two offshore clients in 2011 and 2014 – structures that were intended to hoodwink the authorities into believing the forestry purchases were being made by New Zealanders.
Neither client was a New Zealand citizen or resident.
Negligence, not misconduct
The tribunal found the misconduct charge was not made out because it required a wilful or reckless breach of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act or the conduct rules.
The evidence fell short of showing that Jarvis was aware, at the time of his offending, that his conduct risked breaching his professional obligations, the tribunal said.
“This amounted to blindness rather than wilful blindness on Mr Jarvis’ part.”
In reaching that view, the tribunal took into account his co-operation with the High Court proceedings and the New Zealand Law Society, and his character. After 40 years of practice, this was his only disciplinary issue and his demeanour at the hearing was consistent with his stance that he had not realised he was breaching the overseas investment rules.
But the tribunal found the same unawareness that cleared him of recklessness also pointed “strongly towards a very high level of negligence”.
The tribunal said negligence meant something graver than merely a mistake, the question being whether his mistakes were bad enough to bring the profession into disrepute.
Several features stood out. Jarvis was acting in an unfamiliar field of practice but failed to inform himself properly about the OIA and did not tell his clients he lacked familiarity with the Act. The legislation was squarely within the scope of his engagement and he knew consent was a live issue that would be expensive for his clients.
His structures were caught by the consent rules for more than one reason, so this was “not … a simple matter of overlooking one definition”, the tribunal said. It also noted that the idea of using ‘associates’ in financial transactions appears throughout New Zealand law, including trust, tax and financial markets legislation.
Jarvis made the same fundamental error twice and had multiple opportunities to get it right. In 2014 – on behalf of his second client – he pressed on, despite a prompt from the vendor’s real estate agent about possible OIA issues “that should have alerted a competent practitioner”.
“A prudent practitioner, thinking about the scheme and purpose of the OIA, would have anticipated that the gap he thought he found would have been closed,” the tribunal said, noting that the Act was of national importance.
That the work did not reflect the majority of his practice made no difference, it said.
His actions could readily have be characterised as unsatisfactory conduct, the level of conduct he admitted, but the negligence charge was “the more fitting level”.
Same mistake twice
Jarvis had no previous experience of the OIA when, in 2011, he took instructions from a Singapore-based client who wanted to buy “sensitive land” – a purchase requiring consent from the government.
Three years later, a second buyer approached him wanting a similar structure for the same purpose.
When the real estate agent raised the question of associates, Jarvis emailed that he was instructed the buyer was providing funds to the purchasing company and acting in an advisory capacity, was not involved in its ownership and that another person was the sole shareholder.
The tribunal found that response “was not full and frank” and disclosed “only part of the picture”, though it accepted, as his counsel submitted, that he had no duty to disclose all his client’s affairs to the agent.
The Act’s consent requirements caught both structures because the companies were either overseas persons or associates of overseas persons, the tribunal found. It noted the definition of “associate” in s 8 of the OIA follows immediately after the definition of “overseas person” in s 7.
“From our perspective, the thought that Parliament might have overlooked closing the gap on devices such as Mr Jarvis employed seems naïve,” the tribunal said.
Records showed that Jarvis had not invested time and energy in trying to understand the Act; instead, he appeared to have put his energies into creating the structures rather than reflecting on the legislation or seeking an expert opinion, according to the decision
Penalty to come
Subject to submissions, the tribunal indicated that suspension “does not immediately appear to be required”, and that a censure and fine, plus costs, may be enough where the wrongdoing was neither intentional nor reckless.
It noted the “evident chastening effect” of the proceedings on top of the consequences from High Court ruling.
Counsel for the committee has three weeks to file submissions, with Jarvis’ counsel to follow about a week later.
The tribunal will decide penalty on the papers.
2026-NZLCDT-33-Auckland-Standards-Committee-1-v-Jarvis
The Chief Executive of Land Information New Zealand v Jarvis 2026-NZLCDT-33-Auckland-Standards-Committee-1-v-Jarvis

0 Comments