Neil Sands
An Auckland lawyer struck off for luring an overseas client into a fraudulent property investment scheme has an extensive record of breaching professional standards, including a finding against her for blackmail, a disciplinary tribunal decision has revealed.
The Lawyers & Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal found that its only viable option was to strike off Vivian Ma and order her to pay costs totalling more than $90,000 after considering her record and the defence “built upon falsehoods” that she presented.
“The misconduct in this case was deeply concerning,” the tribunal said in a written decision published this week. “By choosing so unrealistically to deny her wrongdoing, Ms Ma perpetuated our concern about her unfitness to practise. Accordingly, the only proper course is for us to order that her name be struck off the roll of practitioners. In this, we are unanimous.”
Ma was found guilty of misconduct for encouraging an overseas buyer to enter into an unlawful ownership arrangement for a $2 million property in 2020, breaching the Overseas Investment Act.
At the time, Ma was also acting for other parties involved in the transaction, which she did not disclose to the buyer, who lost $650,000 on the deal and brought the complaint against her.
“Her conduct, as revealed by WeChat conversations, deliberately attempted to subvert the law,” the tribunal found. “Her conduct placed the client in jeopardy, and the client suffered financial loss. We found that she was implicated in a fraudulent scheme by luring the client into the transaction while knowing that others looked for undisclosed gain.”
‘Pernicious’ threatening email
In outlining why it had no choice other than to disbar her, the tribunal discussed Ma’s disciplinary record, which includes five matters in addition to the two charges relating to the property transaction.
“Her profile of discipline is concerning. Few practitioners incur so many adverse findings in such a short time. Ms Ma is in her late forties and we do not accept her characterisation of her misconduct as youthful foolishness,” it said.
Prior to being struck off, the most serious charge she faced related to an email that the tribunal found amounted to blackmail. Details were not contained in the latest decision but in a separate one dating back to 2023.
“In relationship property negotiations, she conveyed her client’s threat that, if his offer was not accepted, he would inform Immigration of matters prejudicial to the interests of his former partner,” it said, describing the conduct as “pernicious”.
The tribunal’s liability findings in that case said: “We find this was, essentially, blackmail, a threat to disclose material to Immigration New Zealand for the improper purpose of thereby pressuring the wife to settle.”
It added: “It is alarming that she [Ma] completed a law degree and professional standards training without gaining an appreciation that blackmail is not only criminal but unethical.”
The 2023 decision also revealed Ma admitted unsatisfactory conduct by placing prohibited materials on her desk during a trust account rules exam, although no finding of cheating was made.
In addition, there were three other findings of unsatisfactory conduct for breaches of rules that resulted in fines and retraining orders.
‘Foolhardy’ defence
The tribunal said Ma was dealt with leniently in 2023 but her “cavalier and unlawful misconduct” in the latest case required a level of deterrence “because it bears on the standards and reputation of the profession and the confidence of the public.
“We do not assess that Ms Ma’s practice deficits are susceptible of sufficient change by a period of suspension (even as long as three years) or retraining,” it said. “We accept that she fervently wishes to continue working as a lawyer but a person who is privileged to do so must be able to perform as a responsible, conscientious professional. We assess Ms Ma will be unable to achieve that.”
The tribunal said the cost of the disciplinary proceedings escalated because of Ma’s “bold but foolhardy” defence strategy of denying everything, even in the face of plain evidence. This required the tribunal had to call overseas witnesses and have hundreds of WeChat messages translated.
It said Ma should bear those costs.
“The [costs] quantum has been produced by Ms Ma’s obdurate opposition, her failure to acknowledge that she was the person who advised her client in the WeChat communications. It is unjust for these costs to fall on other practitioners.”
Ma was ordered to pay the Auckland Standards Committee $79,464.14, the New Zealand Law Society $13,776.00.

0 Comments