Mahvash Ikram
A disciplinary tribunal has rejected a last-minute bid from a self-represented lawyer facing being struck off to restart proceedings so she can engage counsel.
Vivian Ma, who was found guilty of misconduct for encouraging an overseas buyer to enter into an unlawful ownership arrangement to purchase a $2 million property, asked the Lawyers and Conveyancers Tribunal to adjourn the matter until she had instructed a lawyer to represent her.
“I’ve decided to restart my case… I do not have a lawyer… now I realize how wrong I am… I can’t defend myself,” Ma told the tribunal at the penalty hearing last week.
But deputy chair John Adams rebuffed her request, saying there was no reason to adjourn and restart the hearing anew.
“We have no evidence from her to support the view that there has been any injustice or lack of proper process in this matter,” he said.
Adams said further delays would add to the already high costs incurred by the case, pointing out a liability hearing for two charges of misconduct was held in March and Ma filed her submissions in May.
“The matter has been on foot for a long time, Ms Ma has been appraised of the charges throughout, she has had our judgment… and has filed her own submissions in response to that decision,” he said.
Acting for the Auckland Legal Standards Committee, barrister Paul Collins told the tribunal that the way Ma ran her defence aggravated the case against her.
In asking for the tribunal to adjourn and then restart the hearing, Ma showed she regretted not having instructed a lawyer to represent her, but did not display any remorse for her actions, Collins said.
“The confessional is about not getting a lawyer, not about the facts of the charges. So, we’re no further ahead,” he said.
The “ultimate sanction” of being struck off was the most appropriate penalty for Ma, who as per s 244 of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006 was not a fit and proper person to be a practitioner, Collins argued.
Background
Ma acted for an overseas buyer – the complainant in the matter – between March and April 2020, facilitating the purchase of an Auckland property via a trust involving the buyer, one of the buyer’s contacts and the contact’s mother (the named purchaser of the property).
Collins said that by giving the complainant advice about the trust ownership agreement, Ma knowingly or recklessly committed an offence under s 43(1) of the Overseas Investment Act 2005 – the section dealing with defeating, evading or circumventing the operation of the Act.
Ma did not notify the complainant of the terms of their engagement, which the complainant was entitled to, and should have received, independent advice about the risks of engaging in a trust ownership arrangement. By wilfully abandoning professional standards, she had showed a “contempt for the law”, Collins said, and in this matter “groomed” a person overseas to engage into an fraudulent transaction.
The buyer’s contact and/or her contact’s mother were also required to apply for consent to purchase a property, as stipulated by the Act, and failure to do so exposed them to an offence under s 42(1).
Collins argued that Ma was a “key actor” in the transaction.
“If a conscientious lawyer had been acting and complied with their duties to establish the relationship properly defining the role they would play and ensuring the absence of conflicts… [one of the] charge[s] would not have happened.”
During the liability hearing, Ma told the tribunal she did not know the complainant, who presented evidence via audio visual link, and refused to cross examine her.
Collins said her behaviour at the hearing was “bizarre”.
“This was a conscious attempt to deflect blame rising to the level of misleading the tribunal. And that’s a serious allegation to make. I accept that and accept the burden of that.”
He added that Ma had provided no evidence to the tribunal that she was not a threat or a peril to the public.
The tribunal will give a written decision in due course.

0 Comments