Mahvash Ikram
A lawyer accused of taking more than $330,000 for personal benefit from his family trust without authority, along with unspecified sums from his parents’ bank accounts while acting as their attorney, is facing a charge of misconduct.
The withdrawals happened over several years, the Lawyers and Conveyancers Tribunal has been told.
On the first day of a three-day hearing this week, the tribunal heard the lawyer – who has name suppression – allegedly breached his fiduciary obligations in relation to his family trust by acting alone as trustee in circumstances where joint action was required. It’s also alleged he withdrew money from his parents’ joint accounts and took money from his mother’s account after her death, without the knowledge of the co-executor of her estate.
According to the Waikato Bay of Plenty Legal Standards Committee, which brought the charge, the lawyer’s behaviour at the time indicated he was not a fit and proper person to practise.
The allegations
Counsel for the standards committee, Sam McMullan, alleged the lawyer – who was a trustee and a beneficiary of the family trust – acted unilaterally when he facilitated four payments from the trust in October and November 2018, even though he was not entitled to exercise trustee discretion alone.
These included three payments of about $100,000 each in October and one payment of around $35,000 in November.
“While he was a trustee, he facilitated payments or loans to himself for his personal benefit without the knowledge or authority of his co-trustee and contrary to the terms of the trust deed… They were payments that he made either to himself or to a law firm that was acting on his instructions for his personal benefit,” McMullan said.
Had the lawyer sought proper authority, the withdrawals would have been legal.
“[According to the deed], the trustees had under their discretion and power to distribute capital and or income for one of the living discretionary beneficiaries, one of those being the lawyer. And the point really is to say there that these trust transactions were ones that could have been made under the trust deed if the proper authority had been undertaken,” he said.
While McMullan acknowledged the lawyer was not disputing that the transactions occurred, he said the committee’s charge related to the allegation that they were carried out without proper authority and were therefore in breach of his fiduciary duties.
However, according to the materials provided by the lawyer, the withdrawals were made in this way because the co-trustee had indicated an intention to resign.
But the other party was in fact still a trustee when the transactions occurred and had not signalled an intention to resign until the end of 2018, after the withdrawals had been made, McMullan said.
Most importantly, the trust deed did not allow him to be the only trustee.
“[The deed says] there can’t be a sole personal trustee… If, at any time, there is only one trustee other than a sole corporate trustee, no power of discretion conferred on the trustees by law or by this deed other than that of appointing a new trustee will be exercised by the sole trustee until such time as an additional trustee has been appointed.”
The lawyer became his parents’ attorney in 2013, after which he made several payments to himself without permission, McMullan said.
His mother was diagnosed with cognitively impairment in late 2015 and passed away in mid-2018. According to her will, the lawyer and his sibling then become joint executors of her estate.
But within 10 days of her death, the lawyer made two withdrawals from his mother’s account without his sibling’s knowledge which, McMullan said, was the strongest element of the case against him.
History of complaint
The financial transactions were first the subject of a complaint in 2010, when one of the lawyer’s siblings – the co-executor of their mother’s estate – raised concerns about its unsecured nature and his management of their parents’ financial affairs.
That complaint was later withdrawn but another was lodged in 2013 concerning the same loan and related dealings.
In 2014, the standards committee resolved to take no further action, relying in part on correspondence from the practitioner’s mother, indicating she was comfortable with the arrangements.
The matter resurfaced in November 2019, when a fresh complaint revived the issues and expanded to include the trustee and payment allegations. That complaint ultimately led to the present charge being filed in 2021.
At an interlocutory hearing in February, the lawyer argued that the proceedings had been marked by significant delay and procedural error and asked the tribunal for a stay.
He argued the delay should not be measured from the latest complaint in 2019 but from earlier proceedings concerning the same subject matter. Even if measured from 2019, he said the passage of time was excessive, telling the tribunal that prolonged exposure to unresolved allegations, professional uncertainty and reputational harm could amount to prejudice.
The tribunal has reserved its decision.

0 Comments