Neil Sands
A lawyer who turned up to court drunk has been censured and barred from practising on her own, with a disciplinary tribunal also noting that she will undergo 12 months of alcohol counselling and face random breath testing at work.
Ms K, who has name suppression, accepted a misconduct charge at a Lawyers & Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal hearing in June, admitting that she suffered alcohol addiction.
The problem reached a head when she attended a judicial conference “and was noted by the judge to be late, somewhat dishevelled and unsteady on her feet”.
The concerned judge asked another lawyer to investigate and Ms K confirmed she was intoxicated.
“It is trite to point out that this conduct in any legal practitioner is totally unacceptable,” the tribunal said in a decision published on Tuesday. “It puts sound representation of clients at risk; it is disrespectful towards the court; and it undoubtedly diminishes the reputation of the profession in the eyes of the public.
“Having said that, we bear in mind that the conduct arises from an illness which must be managed by the practitioner.”
The tribunal noted that it was Ms K’s sixth disciplinary matter and she conceded her record was “awful” but denied her previous problems were alcohol related. However, the tribunal pointed to common themes in her behaviour.
“Certainly, procrastination and unwillingness to face up to problems appear to have been her pattern, and Ms K undertook to explore these issues with her therapist,” it said.
‘Experienced and competent practitioner’
The tribunal said Ms K had previously been working as a sole practitioner “and was clearly feeling isolated and lonely”. She is now employed in a law firm which the tribunal said was extremely supportive of her, adding: “The physical circumstances of the practice mean that any lapse in her sobriety will not go unnoticed.”
The employer has helped Ms K plan medical and therapeutic support. She is attending Alcoholics Anonymous, has undergone a managed detox program, engaged with a therapist and is working with her doctor on taking a medication called disulfiram, which causes a strong adverse reaction in people who drink alcohol.
The tribunal said Ms K had shown genuine remorse and a willingness to work on her alcohol dependency.
“Her employer assures us that she is an experienced and competent practitioner who has much to offer the junior staff whom she now supervises.”
It prohibited her from practising on her own account and ordered her to undergo 12 months of mentoring and alcohol counselling, as well as pay costs totalling $10,752.
It also censured her, saying “when you entered a courtroom while affected by alcohol you let the court, your clients, yourself and your profession down”. It also said her disciplinary record “does you no credit” but accepted she had faced up to her problems and the risk of her conduct being repeated was minimal.
The tribunal granted Ms K permanent name suppression, saying it was taking a rehabilitative approach in the interests of aiding her recovery.

0 Comments