Neil Sands
A disciplinary tribunal has censured Auckland barrister Richard Keam and imposed a $5,000 fine after he admitted speaking to a client “in a rude and highly insulting manner”, noting he immediately regretted the outburst and promptly apologised.
In a number of decisions published this week, the Lawyers & Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal also confirmed a four-month suspension for Auckland lawyer Georgina Grant and a misconduct finding against immigration specialist Yong Keun (Ken) Oh.
The tribunal said that in March last year, Keam was dealing with a client, Mr B, who had “a background of somewhat unreliable attendances at court and meetings”.
Mr B wanted to obtain new counsel, which Keam accepted but the court did not, prompting Keam’s junior to set up a meeting on Friday, March 14.
Mr B did not confirm he would attend, so when he did turn up his arrival was unexpected, leaving Keam frustrated that he had only a weekend to prepare for a week-long jury trial involving a client who had earlier sought to dismiss him.
“Mr Keam also explained in evidence that he perhaps was somewhat more invested in this client than usual because he could see a young man going down a path which would inevitably lead to prison. On the other hand, he also saw a good deal of potential in Mr B,” the tribunal’s written decision said.
Keam launched into a “moralising lecture” during which he berated Mr B and called him offensive names.
Immediately regretting his actions, Keam contact Mr B on the following Monday to apologise and provided a written apology in June, which the tribunal described as “fulsome and genuine”.
“Mr Keam has accepted from the outset that his conduct was completely unacceptable and admitted the breaches of the rules on courtesy towards clients, even to the level of a reckless breach constituting misconduct,” it said. “Mr Keam emphasises that he had let himself down and that all clients deserve respectful treatment.”
The tribunal ordered Keam to make a compensation payment of $5,000 for Mr B’s distress and humiliation, and pay costs of $2,372.
It rejected the National Standards Committee’s request for a $10,000 payment, saying that would require “a much higher level of culpability than the one-off, albeit serious, failure to the client in the current matter.”
‘Evidential vacuum’
Auckland-based barrister Ken Oh appeared before the tribunal in February, accused of charging grossly excessive fees and imposing onerous conditions on his clients which did not put their interests first.
He pleaded guilty to misconduct over the conditions, which threatened migrant workers with penalties of up to $100,000 for breaches, barred them from making complaints about him, and required them to stay in the job he had found for them or face heavy fines.
The tribunal found that Oh was at pains to protect his own business, which involved obtaining visas and job matching, at the expense of his clients who “did not have a fair chance to gauge how poorly they were being served”.
It said the offending was serious and expressed concern that “even at the hearing, Mr Oh’s evidence indicated his lack of understanding about how and why his conduct was problematic”.
It added: “That does not mean we think strike-off is a genuine option, but the need for reassessment and retraining is evident because these are grave gaps for an experienced practitioner to display.”
The tribunal rejected an application from Oh to withdraw a guilty plea to unsatisfactory conduct for overcharging. Clients were charged up to $77,000 by Oh, but the tribunal was unable to assess what was a fair amount because of the unique nature of his business model.
A hearing to determine Oh’s penalty is scheduled for April 29.
‘Continuing inertia’
Georgina Grant was suspended for four months and ordered to pay costs totalling almost $14,000 for failing to engage with the legal profession’s regulator over an extended period regarding two complaints.
The tribunal said lawyers needed to respond to queries from the regulator in a timely fashion.
“Sadly, the tribunal deals with defaults of this kind too often. On occasions like this one …the practitioner has brought this matter upon themselves by simple, continuing inertia,” it said.
The tribunal said over the long period that Grant ignored requests from the standards committee, she managed to run a busy civil litigation practice.
“She has not given these matters any proper priority. Her conduct suggests avoidance, mental block or perhaps a degree of arrogance,” it said.
“Like many practitioners, she has other concerns in her life but unless these obligations are given proper priority, the complaints system will grind to a halt, taking the reputation of the profession and the confidence of the public with it.”

0 Comments