Acting District Court Judge Ema Aitken has kept her job, following a two-week inquiry into her behaviour by a Judicial Conduct Panel.
The panel was examining allegations about Aitken’ conduct at Auckland’s swanky Northern Club in November 2024, where, it was claimed, she disrupted a New Zealand First event and shouted at leader (and then-deputy Prime Minister) Winston Peters.
Aitken denied claims that her behaviour was political or that she had raised her voice.
Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith, in a statement released Friday afternoon, said the panel found that the judge’s behaviour was serious but fell short of the threshold for misconduct that that might warrant consideration of her dismissal.
“The Judicial Conduct Panel has found that Judge Aitken’s actions were a serious breach of comity. Comity requires each branch of government – the executive, the judiciary and the legislature – to act with mutual restraint and respect towards the others.
“However, the panel considered the judge’s conduct fell short of the high threshold of ‘misbehaviour’ necessary to warrant consideration of her removal. Therefore, Judge Aitken will remain an Acting District Court Judge until her warrant expires in February 2027.
Goldsmith said he would not be making any further comment.

0 Comments