Mahvash Ikram
A barrister accused of twice having sex with a client at her home is facing a charge of misconduct before the Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal at a two-day hearing in Auckland.
The practitioner was forced to end the relationship when his wife – a close friend of the client – found out about the affair after seeing a text message on her husband’s phone. The client then laid a complaint with the Law Society but the practitioner told a standards committee that the pair were not in a sexual relationship.
The complainant had known the practitioner for more than 30 years, having met him through his wife, whom she knew from her school days. She regarded him as a trusted family friend. They socialised, attended family events together and visited each other’s homes.
Later, the complainant separated from her husband and moved to Auckland. The practitioner began acting for her in January 2018, which included handling a relationship property dispute and a dispute about a joint family trust, both arising from her divorce.
The practitioner did not send the complainant a formal written retainer recording the terms of engagement until 2020. The standards committee alleges the two had had sex twice by then, and that on one of those occasions he stayed the night.
In April 2022, just days after the lawyer’s wife confronted the client about the affair, the practitioner told the woman he could no longer act for her, citing a “conflict of interest”. She asked him to continue as her lawyer but in June 2022 he terminated the retainer and transferred her file to another lawyer.
The National Legal Standards Committee 1 has charged the practitioner with misconduct under s 7(1)(a)(i) and/or s 7(1)(a)(ii) of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006 by entering into an intimate personal relationship with a client that the committee says was vulnerable. It says this is also a breach of rr 5, 5.7, 5.7.1 and/or 10 of the Conduct and Client Care Rules.
The second charge is in relation to the misrepresentations the practitioner made to the committee in February 2025 by denying he had a sexual relationship with the woman, knowing that it was dishonest and showed intention to deceive. The committee has proposed the alternative charge of unsatisfactory conduct under s 12(b) and/or s 12(c).
There are permanent orders suppressing the complainant’s details and interim suppression orders in relation to the practitioner.
The threshold
The issue was not whether a connection formed between the lawyer and his client, but how far the connection went, counsel for the standards committee told the tribunal.
At the heart of the matter was the lawyer’s duty to act free of compromising influences and loyalties, she said, while also acknowledging the misrepresentation allegation would depend on the tribunal’s decision about the extent of the relationship.
The hearing would be “very much an exploration into thresholds,” the tribunal’s deputy chair, John Adams, said.
“At what threshold did this relationship reach? And was it, or to what extent was it inconsistent with professional rules.”
Counsel for the practitioner said this was a friendship that deepened over time during the professional engagement, but not in a way that was improper or unprofessional. Feelings developed at the very end, there was a brief kiss and he terminated the retainer shortly afterwards because of the conflict that had arisen.
That conduct, viewed in context, “doesn’t meet the threshold for an adverse disciplinary finding in this case,” she said.
‘Mates rates’
According to the written retainer, the practitioner was charging what lawyers call ‘mates’ rates’, equivalent to civil legal aid rates for the Family Court and High Court, his lawyer said, because his involvement arose from friendship.
His fees were not payable until her share of the relationship property was finalised and the woman accepted it was a good deal, the tribunal heard.
The complainant said she had asked for invoices as the matter went on but had not received them. Nevertheless, she paid $5,000 towards the account but accepted there was no written record of any request.
Adams said since there was no written record of any request for invoices, the matter rested on “oral assertion only”.
Asked whether she was shocked when the bill eventually arrived, she said that was the case because of the amount and also because the invoice came without any breakdown of the charges.
“It was just trusting him blindly,” she said. “I was quite naive.”
The friendship
Under cross-examination, the complainant accepted there had been a long-standing personal relationship between the two before 2018. She agreed they had socialised, that she had described him as a trusted family friend and that they had visited each other’s homes.
She disputed how the retainer came about. She said he had offered to act, that she had not asked him and would not have, because he had told her he did not do Family Court work.
“I certainly didn’t say… will you actually look after, you know, represent me,” she said. “I think he probably felt sorry for me. That’s what I’m assuming.”
Counsel for the practitioner put it to her that she had raised the matter with him and asked him to look at it. She rejected that but accepted she had agreed to him acting.
“I said ‘yes, of course’ because I wasn’t sure what to do and I trusted him.”
The hearing continues.

0 Comments