It is hardly surprising that Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann formulated the “spiral of silence”. She was German and 20 in 1936. That so many Germans remained passive in the face of Hitler’s tyranny has haunted that nation’s political scientists for close to 80 years.
Noelle-Neumann’s formulation – that human beings grow increasingly reluctant to express political opinions that contradict those of the majority, descending slowly into a spiral of silence – has proved a useful addition to the political scientist’s tool-kit.
There is, however, something inescapably dark about her formula, something that reflects badly on the moral stamina of humanity and the durability of democracy. And New Zealanders are by no means exempt from its effect. After all, not wanting to stick one’s head too far above the parapet is a very Kiwi characteristic.
Fortunately, keeping one’s head down is not a habit endorsed by all New Zealanders. An irreducible percentage of them (hopefully larger than the Germans of the 1930s) is not in the least daunted by the fact that their opinions are out of sync with the majority. Their attitude is simply expressed: “When you’re right, you’re right.” The truth is not to be determined by majority vote.
Where this cussed minority might struggle, however, is when the opinion polls reveal just how many of their fellow citizens adhere to views that contradict their own.
This year in particular, election year, the cry arises most plaintively from unabashed conservative voters:
What’s wrong with the polls? Why isn’t National leading Labour by a country mile?
The answer to this question comes in many parts, most of which draw heavily from Noelle-Neumann’s spiral of silence.
Driven largely by the covid-19 pandemic, New Zealand society has become much more polarised, and its people a lot less tolerant of dissent. What’s more, the algorithms of social media are keeping them that way, constantly refining and reinforcing the arguments for treating those who hold opposing views as the enemy.
These social media silos are reproducing a phenomenon first detected among Labour voters in the mid-1970s.
As National’s Rob Muldoon exploited widespread economic and social anxieties to win election after election, the frustration of a certain kind of Labour voter grew. “How does this man win?” cried the well-educated professionals who now backed the Labour Party. “No one I know has ever voted for him!”
Fifty years ago the spiral of silence was working against Labour and in favour of National. It had become embarrassing to express pro-Muldoon views in the university common room and the secondary school staff room. The sharp reaction of their colleagues encouraged conservatives to keep their opinions to themselves.
It was the other way around, however, in many of the nation’s much more numerous smoko rooms. Sticking-up for the Labour leader, Bill “The Mouse” Rowling, all too frequently produced guffaws from one’s workmates, accompanied by that chilling Kiwi query: “Whaddarya?!”
Ultimately, a percentage of those who selfcensored in this fashion ended up embracing the arguments of their colleagues and workmates. At the bottom of the spiral, silence becomes agreement.
Déjà vu
Given the polls, it is possible that something very similar is happening 50 years later.
Among those New Zealanders who drew strength from the team of five million metaphor during the pandemic and then rewarded its promoter Jacinda Ardern with their votes in 2020, an intolerance of negativity and dissent (very strong during the pandemic) may linger.
National’s pollster David Farrar reports that the solidaristic surge to Labour which saw 400,000 habitual National voters – most of them women – swap sides, have yet to surge back.
Roughly half of them are still struggling to reconcile “being kind” with Christopher Luxon’s plutocratic pitch.
At work here could be something similar to the phenomenon observed in France over the past four decades. The French working class, once the backbone of the powerful French Communist Party, has slowly but surely migrated from Left to Right.
Alienated by the communists’ stance on immigration and the steady rise of the disdainful professional and managerial class across the Left, working-class French voters are now among the nationalist Right’s most fervent supporters.
Political scientists have discovered that the faithful partisan’s initial “defection” is always the hardest. Once voters have abandoned their traditional loyalties that critical first time, however, repeating their treachery becomes progressively easier. National’s confident expectation that its female defectors will eventually come to their senses and return to the conservative fold may prove ill-founded.
Certainly, in those professions increasingly dominated by women – education, health, communications, the public service and the notfor-profit sector – an ideological campaign of unprecedented energy has left a great many hitherto conservative women holding cultural and political views markedly at odds with those of men.
Poll failure
Initially, the spiral of silence may have been at work in these workforces. Expressing dissident views about te Tiriti o Waitangi, decolonisation and transgenderism has become an increasingly risky exercise.
But going along to get along, saying as little as possible, it becomes a lot easier (and the prospects of promotion much rosier) the moment an employee convinces herself the official line is her line too.
In addition to the spiral of silence effect leading voters who find themselves out of step with the majority to resile from their previously stated preferences, there are numerous other explanations for the failure of opinion pollsters to accurately forecast the outcome of elections. There’s the “Bradley Effect”, named after the black Democratic Party frontrunner for the California governorship, Tom Bradley, who lost unexpectedly to his white Republican opponent.
Unexpectedly because, when polled, white Democrats were too ashamed to admit to their true, racially-driven preferences.
Then there’s the “Shy Tory Factor”, said to explain why Labour, well ahead in the polls prior to the 1992 UK general election, ended up losing to John Major’s Conservatives.
There were just too many former Labour voters unwilling to admit that they were preparing to vote for the party of Margaret Thatcher.
Boomer minority
In addition to the influence of gender, race and class, the shape of the polls may also be determined by generational factors.
The 2023 general election will be the first in which the baby-boom generation is outnumbered (on the electoral roll, at least) by the generations born after 1965.
Those who demand to know “What’s wrong with the polls?” may simply be interpreting the political terrain through the eyes of someone who grew up in a very different New Zealand to the one fashioned by the reforms of Roger Douglas and Ruth Richardson.
The political stimuli that make the boomers’ knees jerk may not have the same effect on millennials. More numerous, and living longer than any generation before them, the boomers may encounter unprecedented and infuriating difficulties in coming to terms with their minority status.
Angry voters can be dangerous voters – as Brexit and the election of President Donald Trump can attest. Angry American voters have set out to mislead the pollsters, lying to them quite deliberately to make the detested elites feel more confident than was wise. Then there are the voters who nobody expects to show up on the day – like the tens of thousands of perennial non-voters who came out to give the British establishment a bloody nose by voting to leave the European Union.
French political scientists explained these Brexit voters’ motivations by referencing the “five As”: Anomie, Alienation, Austerity, Authoritarianism and Atavism. (All currently doing their destructive best on the streets of France.)
We got our own glimpse of the five As when they paid a visit to Parliament grounds in February and March 2022. We may see them again in October when, goaded to fury by a feral combination of ACT and Te Pāti Māori election policies, the angry youth of urban Māori communities turn up to the polling places for the very first time.
That padding of the Left vote in the opinion polls may indicate the presence of a voting cohort New Zealanders have never encountered before – and were not expecting.
Chris Trotter has been a political commentator for more than 30 years. He is the author of the Bowalley Road blog.
0 Comments