Neil Sands
Tauranga City Council (TCC) ignored multiple warnings dating back decades about the landslide danger posed by a slope that gave way and killed six people at the Mt Maunganui Beachside Holiday Park in January this year, a damning independent review by former High Court judge Paul Davison KC has found.
Davison found the tragedy was preventable and resulted from “deeply systemic flaws” at the council, both on the day of the tragedy and in the years leading up to it.
His 263-page examination – available here – detailed warnings from 2005 by geo-technical experts which identified the exact point where the slip occurred and warned about the risk of multiple fatalities at the TCC-owned and operated campsite.
Those warnings, which the experts repeatedly made to council after the initial study, were ignored, along with separate geo-technical reports in 2023 and 2025 which urged TCC to adopt a Trigger Action Response Plan (TARP) to manage landslide risk at the site.
“This was a systemic failure with tragic consequences. Had a TARP been in place, evacuation would likely have occurred well prior to the fatal landslide and the tragic loss of life that occurred would in all likelihood have been averted,” Davison said.
Davison, who was commissioned to carry out the review by TCC, did not make any findings of criminal, civil, or disciplinary liability, in line with his terms of reference.
Separate inquiries into the landslip are also being conducted by police, the coroner, WorkSafe and the government (administered by the Department of Internal Affairs).
Lack of foresight, robust processes
In addition to failings in the years leading up to the disaster, Davison also said TCC missed multiple opportunities to evacuate in the 24 hours before the deaths occurred at about 9.30am on January 22, when a landslide engulfed the campsite’s amenities block.
A state of emergency was in place at the time, as the area experienced its heaviest rainfall in more than 20 years, with 199.3mm recorded on January 21 and 96.1mm on January 22.
Davison said the first opportunity to evacuate was when MetService issued a rare “red heavy rain warning” for Bay of Plenty on January 21. The second was when the forecast deluge eventuated, followed by more missed chances for action when warning signs, such as smaller slips above the campground and a steady stream of muddy water flowing above the amenities block, were spotted but ignored.
“It is important to be clear about what this review does not find. It does not find that any individual did anything intentionally or deliberately wrong, or that any one or more persons’ acts or omissions caused these tragic deaths… Those TCC staff and members of the public alike, who ran towards the danger, and searched desperately for those who were trapped, deserve to be acknowledged and commended for their bravery and selfless humanity,” he said.
‘What this review does find is that this tragedy was, in the end, preventable. I do not mean by that that anyone could have known that this slope would fail at this moment, on this particular morning – no one could.
“I mean something more deeply troubling: that the hazard was known, that an effective and inexpensive means of managing the risk it posed had twice been recommended, and that the council had every opportunity to put it in place.
“Had it done so, the most consequential decision of January 22 – whether to move people away from the foot of the slope – would not have been left to the unaided judgement of whoever happened to be on site that morning. It would have been made in advance, against defined criteria that the readily observable conditions of that day would plainly have met.
“What was required was not extraordinary foresight. It was the robust operational processes and discipline required of a well-run organisation: that a known risk to life be owned by someone, recorded, escalated, and followed through until an effective means of mitigating it was in place, and that those left in charge of the campground were equipped to recognise the danger, and ready to act quickly and effectively if ever required.”

0 Comments