Jenni McManus
Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith has refused a request from The Law Association (TLANZ) to make a minor amendment to the Lawyers & Conveyancers Act 2006 (LCA) which would have enabled TLANZ and its members to share in the distribution of assets from the Solicitors’ Fidelity Guarantee Fund (SFGF).
The fund, set up under the Law Practitioners Act in 1982 to cover theft by lawyers, closed in August 2008 when the LCA came into effect and a new Lawyers’ Fidelity Fund was established. According to the New Zealand Law Society’s (NZLS) annual report for 2023-2024, the SFGF now stands at $14.92 million, mostly in cash and bonds.
NZLS began winding up the fund in 2022 and an Order in Council, deeming the fund to be wound up, is believed to be imminent. At that point the residual assets of the fund can be distributed.
Of the $14.92m, one third is required under s 369 of the LCA to be transferred to the Lawyers’ Fidelity Fund. The remaining two-thirds – the thick end of $10m – “must” remain with NZLS and be used “by that society” for its representative functions, the legislation says.
Other priorities
Earlier this year, TLANZ approached Goldsmith, asking for the words “by that society” be removed and replaced with “to bodies representing lawyers and conveyancers who have been approved by the minister”. TLANZ also noted that the Regulatory Systems (Occupational Regulation) Amendment Bill was, at the time, before the Education and Workplace Select Committee and included six substantial amendments to the LCA.

Paul Goldsmith
But Goldsmith said his ministry was simply too busy to consider it.
“The primary reason is that it would have required changing the legislation and we already have an extremely busy legislative agenda. I just couldn’t justify having legislation focused on that when we’ve got so many other pieces of legislation that we need to get on with,” he told LawNews.
TLANZ President Tony Herring said he was disappointed that the minister has decided not to amend the legislation because of more pressing priorities.

Tony Herring
“But TLANZ will continue its role as the leading independent organisation upholding the rule of law and voicing the needs and concerns of the profession with government, the judiciary, the regulator and the range of stakeholders that impact the practice and business of law,” he said.
“NZLS should also be telling the profession about its plans for the $9 million+ it will receive from the SFGF for representative functions. How and when does the regulator of our profession intend to apply those funds to ensure it fulfils the ‘representative functions’ requirements of s 369(2) of the LCA, and is the intention to represent all members of the profession or only those who have paid to join the NZLS membership program?
Levies paid
TLANZ CEO Clayton Kimpton said the organisation considered it necessary to raise the issue with Goldsmith because the profession’s representative landscape had changed significantly since the enactment of the LCA and the decision of the Auckland District Law Society (now TLANZ) not to merge with NZLS.
“TLANZ was the only district law society not to merge with NZLS, carving its way – along with other practice group and sector associations – as a representative body for the profession that is completely independent of the regulator (NZLS). TLANZ membership now sits at 8,200+, many of whom actually paid the SFGF levies that created the fund,” he said.

Clayton Kimpton
“TLANZ considered that s 369(2)(b) of the LCA should have been amended to reflect that diversity of representation, independent of the regulator. NZLS has only recently, in 2024, established a membership representative function, which appears well-timed for its receipt of the SFGF representative distribution, but highlights the conflict NZLS now has as both the regulator and one of the profession’s many representative bodies.
“TLANZ members have exercised their freedom to associate with TLANZ to represent them. However, they will not get the benefit of the SFGF funds being applied to their representation without paying an additional annual membership fee of $290 to NZLS, in addition to the fee for their practising certificate.”
The conflict between NZLS’ representative and regulatory functions was recognised by NZLS President Frazer Barton when an Independent Review of the profession was undertaken in 2023. In an interview with LawNews in August that year, Barton conceded that many lawyers believed that the dual role of NZLS as watchdog and representative “doesn’t serve the interests of the profession and the public well”.
The Independent Review Panel recommended an independent regulator should be appointed for the profession.
In the absence of a new regulator being established, NZLS has proposed a reform package for the LCA. Read more here
The TLANZ submission on the reform package is available here.

0 Comments