Chris Trotter
Why does this election feel so different?
We New Zealanders, along with our Australian neighbours, treat ourselves to three general elections per decade. That’s about 20 elections in the average Kiwi’s lifespan. One would think we’d all be this side of blasé about the triennial democratic ritual – but not this time. This time it’s different.
Tim Murphy, over at the Newsroom website, compares it with an election held more than 20 years ago:
Not since the 2005 election campaign, when a group of Exclusive Brethren businessmen attempted to secretly back the National Party through a $1.2m ad campaign targeting Labour and the Greens, has NZ faced such a febrile campaign climax.
Febrile? It’s a great word, albeit one that has fallen out of general use. My trusty AI assistant defines it like this:
Febrile is an adjective that means having or relating to a fever. It is derived from the Latin word febris, meaning fever.
The word is used in two primary context. In medicine, febrile describes the physical symptoms, phases, or conditions associated with an elevated body temperature:
Used in a figurative or literary context, febrile describes a state of intense, nervous energy, excitement, or agitation.
Intensity. Nervousness. Excitement. Agitation. That covers it nicely. This has not been the sort of election New Zealanders take in their stride. To a much greater degree than is usually the case in New Zealand politics, who wins and who loses this contest matters – a lot – and to a lot more voters than the ever-anxious followers of the parties represented in Parliament.
Though it’s difficult to assess exactly how much, a large measure of this febrility is traceable to the unsettling feeling among voters that if their “side” loses, then the consequences will be difficult, if not impossible, to reverse.
But wait a minute, doesn’t the latest Ipsos poll identify the key issues exercising the electorate in the final week of this election campaign as (in descending order) inflation/cost of living, healthcare/hospitals, petrol price/fuel, the economy and unemployment? Surely, these are all issues that governments can, and should, do something about.
Inflation can be brought down. New hospitals can be built. The Strait of Hormuz won’t remain closed forever. Our economy is already showing signs of growth. Unemployment falls as often as it rises.
None of these issues is beyond the power of our politicians to reverse.
Gaming the system
In theory, that is indisputable. In reality, however, a great many voters have grown sceptical of politicians’ promises to improve the economy. Young people in particular have been educated to believe that politicians do not – and should not – possess the power to steer the economy as a helmsman might steer a ship.
Sir Robert Muldoon may have managed the New Zealand economy as if it were his personal possession, but the economic reforms of the 1980s and 1990s were intended, at least in part, to make such personalised economic management impossible.
The levers of power are lined up in front of our politicians and we pretend to believe that when a cabinet minister gives them a sharp tug, something important happens. Somewhere. Somehow.
But what choice do we have, except to go on believing in the efficacy of political action? Our democracy would stand revealed as pretty useless if it were ever admitted that the cables attached to those impressive economic levers had long ago been cut.
Besides, if it weren’t at least theoretically possible to reattach those cables to the nation’s economic machinery, then why are so many wealthy and powerful people working so hard to prevent the Left bloc from winning the election?
If the markets truly possess the power to negate the democratic mandates of our politicians, then the colour of the winning political party’s rosette really shouldn’t matter, should it?
That so much effort is being expended on gaming the MMP electoral system to produce a parliamentary overhang of sufficient magnitude to more or less guarantee a right-wing victory is a pretty clear sign that those responsible for the “Split Your Vote!” campaign are in no doubt whatsoever that the “system” can indeed be changed – and changed utterly.
Isn’t that the real lesson to be drawn from the trauma of covid? That when the state is called upon to act, it can indeed act. That if billions are needed to keep the nation safe, then billions will be found. That if laws are required to compel the compliance of recalcitrant citizens, then draconian laws will be passed.
Sure, the New Zealand state was shown to be a little rusty when it came to operating the nation’s economic machinery on anything other than the markets’ behalf. But socialism turns out to be like riding a bike– it soon comes back to you.

Sir Rob Muldoon
A darker hue

Chlöe Swarbrick
Perhaps that’s why the nightmare of Chlöe Swarbrick riding her socialist trailbike over the rubble of neoliberal New Zealand is costing Christopher Luxon and Nicola Willis so much sleep.
Notwithstanding the National Party’s counterproductive obsession with the Greens’ co-leader, there are other and better reasons to oppose the return of the Left bloc than the fiscal policies of its component parties.
The cultural radicalism of the Left, and Opportunity, is both real and frightening – the reason, presumably, why so much of it is being kept out of sight until the last ballot has been cast and counted.
There was a time when the incrementalism of the centre-left was regarded as a positive political attribute. The implementation of a public plan, one small step at a time, was widely understood to be the most responsible course for a social-democratic party to follow. Implementing everything, everywhere, all at once is just asking for trouble.
But today’s left-wing incrementalism has taken on a darker hue. Implementing a hidden agenda, one tiny step following another – none of them in and of themselves revolutionary – will nonetheless add up to a revolution, eventually. Like a disassembled sniper’s rifle, the instrument’s purpose and lethality becomes evident only as the process of putting it together reaches its end.
Hidden in plain sight
There are forums, however, where the quiet parts of the “progressive” movement’s agenda are spoken out loud.
Every long march through the institutions receives its orders from somewhere. Here are some samples from an organisation calling itself (entirely appropriately) “Reshaping Democracy”.
One of the “work streams” emerging from this think tank’s “unconference” envisages “implementing Matike Mai Aotearoa, constitutional transformation, tikanga as law, consensual conciliatory democracy and more.” More? Isn’t that enough?
Apparently not. Under the heading “Participatory and Deliberative Democracy”, another work stream promotes “participatory and deliberative democracy, including rebalancing politics from opinion to judgement, citizens’ assemblies, practising civics, open budgets, and more.”
That “free and fair elections” are nowhere to be found in this list is, surely, a little worrying? And what, exactly, does “rebalancing politics from opinion to judgement” mean?
Jumping at shadows? Maybe. But it is worth recalling that the detailed plan for constitutional transformation known as the He Puapua report was once a collection of suggestions from an Ardern government-appointed group of te Tiriti-promoting incrementalists, whose existence and deliberations were hidden from the public (along with Labour’s coalition partner NZ First).
Seven years later, one of that group, Kayla Kingdon-Bebb, is ranked number four on Opportunity’s party list. If the party crests the 5% MMP threshold, then Kingdon-Bebb will become a New Zealand legislator.
Capital gains, inheritance and wealth taxes are by no means the only reasons for right-wing New Zealanders to feel unusually apprehensive about the outcome of the election.
There are reasons, too, why left-wing Kiwis are awaiting the outcome of this electoral battle with something approaching dread. They are afraid that, to paraphrase Al Jolson in the world’s first talking picture, they ain’t seen nothing yet.
Votes as weapons
Throughout this country’s history there have been elections where New Zealanders deployed their votes as tools to construct a better future. The election of 1938 was one such: the institutions it consolidated would shape New Zealand society for the next 80 years.
Other elections have seen people’s votes used as shields against a party manifesto that promised only division and chaos. As Newsroom’s Tim Murphy observed, in its final few days the 2005 contest was transformed into a shield election.
Sadly, there have also been elections where New Zealanders used their votes as weapons. The “Dancing Cossacks” election of 1975, which ushered in the divisive Muldoon era, was one in which voting was expertly weaponised.
By the evening of Saturday, 7 November 2026, many New Zealanders may be coming to terms with another weaponised election.
Indeed, it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that, as evening blurs into morning, at least half the population will either be discovering for the first time, or reluctantly becoming reacquainted with, the acute anxiety of living in a political environment that is reaching fever pitch.

Chris Trotter has more than 30 years’ experience as a political analyst and commentator. He is the author of the Bowalley Road blog.

I think Chris Trotter is looking at this election through too narrow a lens. The fundamental divide in our society is not simply Left versus Right, but increasingly top versus bottom. It is about who holds economic and political power, whose interests that power serves, and how it is exercised.
There is a reason those with wealth and influence benefit from keeping ordinary people divided along party, racial, cultural and ideological lines. While we argue amongst ourselves, we pay less attention to the concentration of wealth, the influence of money in politics and the policies that determine how resources and opportunities are distributed.
What concerns me about Trotter’s analysis is the disproportionate suspicion he directs towards progressive constitutional reform, Te Tiriti and greater Māori participation, while giving insufficient attention to the exercise of power and institutional changes being pursued by the current Government. Why should one side’s proposed changes be treated as a democratic threat while the other’s are not subjected to the same scrutiny?
None of this means our differences are unimportant. Nor should constitutional reform be beyond scrutiny. But the debate needs to be about democratic legitimacy, accountability and the distribution of power, not simply which ideological camp poses the greater threat.
Ultimately, this election should prompt us to ask a much bigger question: are our democratic institutions working in the interests of all New Zealanders, or are economic and political power becoming increasingly concentrated in the hands of those who already have the most influence?
That is the question I think deserves far greater attention.