LawNews:

Enjoy access to premium content, expert analysis, and industry updates.

x

Home 5 Featured 5 Why who wins this election matters a whole lot more than usual

Sign in below or
become a Member
to join the discussion.

Commenting Guidelines

Join the conversation by adding your comments to this story. Comments on this site are moderated before publication to encourage respectful and civil debate. By submitting your comment, you agree to our commenting rules available here.

1 Comment

  1. Dara

    I think Chris Trotter is looking at this election through too narrow a lens. The fundamental divide in our society is not simply Left versus Right, but increasingly top versus bottom. It is about who holds economic and political power, whose interests that power serves, and how it is exercised.

    There is a reason those with wealth and influence benefit from keeping ordinary people divided along party, racial, cultural and ideological lines. While we argue amongst ourselves, we pay less attention to the concentration of wealth, the influence of money in politics and the policies that determine how resources and opportunities are distributed.

    What concerns me about Trotter’s analysis is the disproportionate suspicion he directs towards progressive constitutional reform, Te Tiriti and greater Māori participation, while giving insufficient attention to the exercise of power and institutional changes being pursued by the current Government. Why should one side’s proposed changes be treated as a democratic threat while the other’s are not subjected to the same scrutiny?

    None of this means our differences are unimportant. Nor should constitutional reform be beyond scrutiny. But the debate needs to be about democratic legitimacy, accountability and the distribution of power, not simply which ideological camp poses the greater threat.

    Ultimately, this election should prompt us to ask a much bigger question: are our democratic institutions working in the interests of all New Zealanders, or are economic and political power becoming increasingly concentrated in the hands of those who already have the most influence?

    That is the question I think deserves far greater attention.

Submit a Comment

Related Content

Why criminal defendants should be granted permanent name suppression

Employment disputes split Crown Law, Solicitor-General under fire over planned reset and restructure

Commerce Commission lays down AI guidance and obligations for business

Employment Court seeks feedback on draft practice directions for non-lawyers

No results found.