Mahvash Ikram
A new check-in feature on Microsoft Teams that allows bosses to track when an employee is present in the office could creep into Big Brother territory, sparking wider concerns about workplace surveillance, privacy experts say.
The tool automatically updates a user’s Teams status to “in office” when their laptop connects to the corporate Wi-Fi_33 network. Microsoft describes it as an “opt‑in convenience feature”, designed to help colleagues see who is physically present on-site.
But the choice to opt-in masks the power imbalance inherent in the workplace that makes the feature open to abuse, says Amy Kingston‑Turner, commercial director at Source Legal and a member of The Law Association’s Technology & Law Committee.
“Can you really opt out?” she asks. “Because if that’s the culture of the workplace you work in…it’s very hard to opt out. I think it’s very, very open to misuse.”
Kingston‑Turner said there was a risk that the check-in feature could turn into a surveillance tool that borders on harassment. “At what point does it go into a slippery slope of surveillance?”
Privacy and employment lawyer Kathryn Dalziel concurs, saying the check-in feature is “the thin edge of the wedge”.
“I’m trying to work out what problem it’s trying to fix,” she said. “If you want a meeting with somebody, you can ring them or send them an email. I just ask myself the question, ‘why do you need it?’”
Like Kingston-Turner, Dalziel warns that check-in could lead to “function creep”, morphing from a convenience to surveillance. Petty conflicts could arise about legitimate employee movements around the office, such as bathroom breaks or the micro‑breaks encouraged in health and safety guidelines.
The best idea, she said, was to go to the workstation of the person you’re looking for. “Get up from your desk and go for a walk. It won’t kill you. In fact, it will do the opposite.”
Boundary issues
Simon Schofield, a professional teaching fellow at the University of Auckland’s Law School and member of The Law Association’s Employment Law Committee, said check-in could become part of a creeping normalisation of workplace surveillance that reached into employees’ private lives.
For example, data from a company‑supplied wearable device that tracks sleep, heart rate and physical activity could be used as a monitoring tool by employers, enabling them to make assumptions about performance.
“Boundaries should be put in place to ensure that employees in that situation are protected,” he said. For example, you wouldn’t necessarily want your employer to know you’d had only three hours’ sleep the previous night because the employer might then make assumptions about your likely work performance the following day.
“That’s not healthy – there is an element of Big Brother,” Schofield said.
Presence is not productivity
The Employment Relations Act requires a relationship built on trust and confidence, and constant workplace monitoring suggests the opposite, Dalziel said.
“It just suggests the employer doesn’t have trust and confidence in the person. The key thing every employer wants is productivity, not being at your desk. This is not a measure of productivity.”
Kingston-Turner agrees. “Employers don’t own employees… [They] should be judged on the deliverables they create, not how many hours they spend sitting at a desk.”
Dr Alex Baird, a University of Auckland lecturer in electrical, computer and software engineering, said the most important safeguard was transparency before a feature such as check-in was activated.
“Doing that without a conversation is something that I would raise an eyebrow about,” he said.
Not performance management
The feature, delayed last year but now being rolled out, relies on a laptop’s Wi‑Fi connection to determine location. It does not use GPS or store data beyond the end of the working day.
The tool could be genuinely helpful for hybrid teams, Baird said.
“[I] am pretty inconsistent about whether I’m in the office or not. The ability to just have that status updated without me needing to remember is quite a useful little feature,” he said.
Microsoft has made it clear that the system is not intended to be a performance‑management instrument and because location information is not retained, a manager wanting to misuse it would have to manually take notes, Baird said.
“If the data is being collected for improving communication around the office, not performance management, then to use it for performance management is not appropriate.”

0 Comments