It has been just shy of three years since the Privacy Act 2020 (Act) came into force, replacing the 1993 legislation of the same name.
It has been just shy of three years since the Privacy Act 2020 (Act) came into force, replacing the 1993 legislation of the same name.
A recurring issue for employers is how the request provisions of the Act are being used by some employees during disciplinary and investigation processes. The effect of this approach, whether intended or not, is often frustration and delay. We examine this issue and ways to mitigate risk.
What’s required?
Broadly speaking, the Act governs the collection, storage, use, disclosure and access to and correction of personal information by agencies through various information privacy principles (IPPs) and sections of the Act. The key terms are of course “personal information” and “agency’”, which are defined as:
Personal information: Information about an identifiable individual, being a natural person (not a corporate) that is alive.
Agency: Any person (including an individual, corporation, body corporate or unincorporated body), that collects or holds personal information. Notably, this can include overseas people who are carrying on business in New Zealand.
The two terms are intentionally broad. Really, any information that directly identifies, or identifies by reasonable inference, an individual is considered personal information. Any party that has collected or holds that information is considered an agency.
Another article could feasibly be written on the requirements of the IPPs and the Act as to collection, storage, use, disclosure and correction of personal information. For the purposes of this article, however, we focus on how the Act governs access to personal information. To summarise:
- Any person can make a request for personal information from an agency;
- Once a request is made, the agency must respond as soon as reasonably practicable, but no later than 20 working days;
- “Responding” to the request is letting the requestor know whether the agency will grant or refuse access (or in some cases neither confirm nor deny that the information is held);
- If the agency decides to refuse access for whatever reason, it must tell the requestor on what grounds it is making that decision and inform them that they can complain to the Privacy Commissioner; and
- If the agency needs more time to respond to a request, it must (within the 20-working-day period) inform the requestor of the period of extension, the reasons why and of their right to complain to the Privacy Commissioner.
Using the Act as a sword
The reason for providing a pathway for individuals to access their personal information is sound. The information is about them and they should have access equal to the agency that holds it.
While most individuals will utilise the access pathway for genuine reasons that are consistent with the purposes of the Act, there are instances where requests are made for other motives.
The most common example occurs during an employer-run investigation or disciplinary process. During that process, the employee who is the subject of the investigation or process may request information under the Act, often about matters that have nothing to do with the process the employer is running. Concurrent to making the request, the employee may refuse to engage in the employer’s process until he/she has received the requested information.
The above approach puts the employer in a difficult position – whether it continues the process (and deals with the information request separately) or halts the process until it has met the employee’s demand. Related to this question, other risks can often be front-of-mind for employers:
- If they proceed without first addressing the request, are any resulting decisions (termination, for example) potentially unjustified?
- Will halting the process and providing the requested information simply lead to more information requests and more delay from the employee?
- If information is provided, is there potentially something in there that is problematic and may assist the employee in raising a personal grievance?
- Is the potential scope of information so wide that it would take weeks to comply with?
The effect of such a request is disarray and often delay. It shifts the focus from being solely on the employee to the employer as well. The prescriptive nature of the Act can often trip employers up when faced with this issue.
When things go wrong
If an individual has a privacy complaint, their first avenue for redress is through the Office of the Privacy Commissioner (OPC). The OPC may investigate the complaint in accordance with natural justice principles and make a determination on the substance of the complaint.
It may also refer the complaint to the Director of Human Rights Proceedings to litigate the issue. Further, the OPC can issue an access direction to the agency, requiring it to comply with an information request (this power was not provided for under the 1993 legislation).
While the OPC is unable to make orders as to financial remedies, it is by no means toothless. It can, however, take several months for the OPC to conclude its investigation.
Once the OPC process has been exhausted, the individual can then litigate through the Human Rights Review Tribunal (HRRT). This too can be a long process. Unlike the OPC, the HRRT can award financial remedies for:
- Pecuniary damages, based on tangible loss and expense causally related to the breach.
- Loss of benefit, which need not be monetary but must be a benefit that was expected but for the breach.
- Humiliation, loss of dignity and injury to feelings, being entirely intangible. In a similar way to the employment jurisdiction, damages under this head are banded
The HRRT can also compel an agency to take action, restrain an agency from taking any action, order an agency to apologise and impose penalties (for example, a penalty for failing to comply with an access direction). This is non-exhaustive, but indicative of the wide powers afforded to the HRRT.
The short point is that a failure to address an information request, or fulfil a request, in accordance with the Act is an easily made mistake that carries comparable risk for employers. An information request that may seem just a frustrating detour can develop into lengthy litigation, costing a business legal fees, remedies, and executive time.
Mitigating risk
The most important way to mitigate risk is to take care when recording information, be that in emails, texts, notes or anything else written.
The guiding principle is that any information about an individual is accessible. There are, however, limited exceptions to that principle. For example, if information is genuinely evaluative and is provided in confidence, it may be withheld.
In dealing with a request for information during an employer run process, there is no “correct” approach. Employers can, however, make the issue easier for themselves:
- If the request concerns information that ought to be provided to the employee to enable him/her to participate in the process, then that information should be provided before the process continues. For example, an employee being disciplined should already have information relevant to the allegations.
- If the request concerns information irrelevant to the process, then it is permissible to continue the process and deal with the request in accordance with the Act.
- Most requests will contain a mix of the above two Employers can therefore elect to separate the categories and deal with them as set out above. It is advisable, and consistent with good faith obligations, to tell the employee why the request is being handled this way.
Approaching the request as above will assist where the request is broad and covers a wide range of information. Most requested information will not be relevant to the employer run process, so separating that aspect of the request early is essential.
Separation, however, ensures only that the employer can proceed with the process. It does not mean the employer is absolved from actually addressing the request.
An employer can extend the timeframe for responding to a request. There is no absolute limit to how long an extension can be, but use common sense. When considering an extension, it is useful to factor in the amount of information sourced, the potential storage areas for that information and the internal resources to collate and review information.
If it is likely that a long extension is necessary, it is reasonable to write to the employee and offer the opportunity to refine the request. If the employee is keen to obtain the information sooner, he/she will be motivated to make their request more specific.
Finally, employers need to be mindful of what they give employees in response to a request. Any information that concerns other individuals may be withheld or redacted to avoid unwarranted disclosure of someone else’s personal information. Any privileged or commercially sensitive information may also need to be withheld.
Helen Pryde is a senior associate at Duncan Cotterill and a member of the ADLS Employment Law committee.
0 Comments