Jenni McManus
The Employment Court has again called out what it describes as the ‘unprofessional’ and ‘abusive’ conduct of a prominent employment advocate, with the latest rebuke coming from Judge Kathryn Beck in a decision involving the advocate, Lawrence Anderson, and barrister Catherine Stewart.

Catherine Stewart
Stewart, the convenor of The Law Association’s Employment Law Committee, had sued Anderson personally for indemnity costs after she was hit with an application for non-party discovery, brought by Anderson, that she considered vexatious, frivolous and a deliberate abuse of process. The application, Stewart said, had also been disruptive, costly and time-consuming, and Anderson’s conduct “constituted sustained harassment”.
Beck agreed, awarding Stewart the $2500 costs she had asked for and noted that Anderson had been warned about his behaviour in an earlier judgment and told it would not be tolerated by the court.
“I consider Mr Anderson’s conduct to be most improper and indicative of someone who has entered the arena in their own right, as opposed to that of the client,” she said. “This is entirely unacceptable.”
As part of her judgment, Beck included an email Anderson sent on 25 February this year to a third party who forwarded it to Stewart. In it, Anderson refers to the “stupidity” of a member of the Employment Relations Authority and describes allegations about his own conduct as “bullshit”. In a reference to the Employers & Manufacturers Association and the NZ Business Association, Anderson said: “I have asked if they want to pull their finger out of their arses and intervene…[they] are messing around and probably do not know how to write up an intervening application. Please don’t subscribe to those idiots.”
Anderson’s email continues: “The LinkedIn community, most of the names of people who like and comment, they are dumb arses and most of them I have dealt with in employment disputes. Reading, writing, comprehension, it is all out the window with them.”
Lawyers who work in the employment law jurisdiction, Anderson said, “are incapable of dealing with matters that require the use of the human brain”.
Regulation needed

Judge Kathryn Beck
Beck’s rebuke is not the first time an Employment Court judge has reprimanded Anderson for his conduct towards opposing counsel.
Late last year, Judge Joanna Holden publicly bemoaned the fact that because Anderson was not a lawyer, the courts had only limited ability to deal with his conduct. Holden noted that his “unprofessional and abusive conduct” included subjecting opposing counsel to repeated harassment, including texts, emails and phone calls – one of them at 1.21am on the day of a substantive hearing, and leaving one-star Google reviews on opposing counsel from multiple accounts.
Stewart, meanwhile, has repeated her call for the government to regulate employment advocates.
The issue of their behaviour has been a concern within the employment law jurisdiction for more than 20 years, she said, and was crying out for legislative reform.
“At present, anyone can set themselves up as an employment advocate and represent clients, including taking their cases to court. There is no need for advocates to have any relevant qualifications, experience or expertise in employment law, and the public is commonly confused and does not understand that their representative is not a lawyer.
“Unregulated advocates can result in huge problems in cases – such as time delays, cost escalation and stress arising from dealing with advocates who engage in unprofessional or even abusive behaviour…. We have seen many situations where clients have suffered through poor representation by advocates, and the clients often feel misled as they believed their case was being handled by a lawyer.”
Stewart said she had taken court action against Anderson to hold him to account.
“As the judgment records, my view was that a costs’ order against Mr Anderson personally was the only means of regulating his conduct, which I feared would continue in the absence of tangible outcomes such as adverse costs’ awards.
“I took a principled stand in this case to hold this advocate’s behaviour to account and draw a line in the sand about basic standards of conduct. I hope that this will disincentivise poor conduct and will assist our employment law jurisdiction in dealing with these types of situations or, even better, preventing them from happening in the first place.”
She noted that Anderson had already been reprimanded by the court in two prior judgments, and in a third judgment there had been a costs uplift on account of his behaviour.
“However, the court’s decision in this judgment goes further than any of those prior judgments, as it imposes a costs award against him personally. This is a rare outcome but one that the judge determined was warranted.”
Stewart’s move was prompted by a non-party discovery application Anderson made against Stewart that related to a former client. The court noted that this application was unlikely to succeed because of solicitor-client privilege and Stewart herself told Anderson that the material he sought was not relevant. She then filed a costs application against him, saying that he knew, or ought to have known, that the application was vexatious and frivolous and that he was acting in a manner that no proper or dispassionate representative would have acted.
Anderson said his application for discovery was necessary and made for good reason and in good faith.
Beck’s judgment also records his view that there had been no egregious behaviour on his part that would warrant indemnity costs. Anderson said Stewart’s submission was a reputational attack and complained that her staff had been rude and made comments designed to hurt him.
He characterised his own behaviour as “intemperate comments” which should be taken in jest. And as they fell outside the court’s jurisdiction, they could not be considered relevant to a costs application, he said.
Read Judge Beck’s decision here
Read our case note here

As an employment advocate, I am obviously concerned by Mr Andersons behavior, however one bad apple does not make the hole barrel rotten. I would suggest that the majority of advocates are suitably qualified and behave in the appropriate manner towards both the courts and opposing council.
Any regularly requirement will in my opinion raise the cost of practice for advocates which will by necessity be passed on to the client. I would suggest that in a lot if not most of the decisions to employ an advocate rather than a practicing lawyer cost would play a prominent part of the decision making and by increasing the cost of practice for advocates all that will happen is the client suffers through lack of chose.
Possibly the best way to deal with these repeat delinquent advocates is not to see them. treat them as the court would treat a vexatious litigant.
With respect, it’s time for unregulated ‘no win no fee’ advocates being able to ‘represent’ grievant claimants to end.