Application for leave to appeal judgment of Employment Court – Employment Relations Act 2000, s 214 – is it in the interests of justice to grant the extension of time sought? – are there questions of law which are of general or public importance or for any other reason ought to be submitted to the Court of Appeal for determination?
Minister of Education v Cronin-Lampe [2024] NZCA 382
Kathleen and Ronald Cronin-Lampe are a married couple who worked at Melville High School as school counsellors for about 14 years.
During this time, the school community suffered a significant amount of trauma, including approximately 32 deaths in the community, some of which were by suicide or unexpected tragedy.
Kathleen and Ronald assisted the school students, staff and community in relation to these events.
In November 2011, Kathleen and Ronald were both provisionally diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
They raised personal grievances against the school in January 2012, alleging that health and safety and workplace obligations had not been met and that the school had breached health and safety duties in their employment contracts.
Kathleen and Ronald’s claims in the Employment Relations Authority did not succeed. They then took the matter to the Employment Court.
In the Employment Court, Judge Corkill identified 2 December 2010 as the date that the grievances and primary health and safety breaches arose.
He found that both Kathleen and Ronald were afflicted by PTSD prior to this date, although they didn’t know this until they were diagnosed in late 2011.
After diagnosis, Kathleen and Ronald had received advice from a clinical psychologist that it would not be desirable to undertake treatment while engaged in litigation.
As a result, their PTSD remained untreated, and the impacts continued for an extended period.
The judge found that the school had breached express and implied contractual health and safety duties from December 2010 and that it had not acted as a fair and reasonable employer in identifying and managing the issues that had arisen.
The question of the available damages was complex and included issues as to damages available under the Employment Relations Act 2000 and contract, along with questions of causation, remoteness and contribution.
The judge calculated the damages award in both contract and under the Act, adopting the contract sum as it was greater.
There was a reduction of 5% to reflect the contributory behaviour of Kathleen and Ronald in not disclosing the health issues afflicting them to the school.
The result was total awards of $829,355 to Kathleen and $962,962 to Ronald, which included non-economic damages (mental injury) and economic damages (lost income, superannuation, loss on sale of rental investment, loss of rental income and medical expenses).
The Employment Court judgment was released on 5 December 2023.
Melville High School was scheduled to close on 27 January 2024 with the Minister of Education then to inherit responsibility for these proceedings.
The minister filed an application for leave to appeal and an application for an extension of time on 29 January 2024 (the statutory time frame had expired on 3 January 2024).
The minister’s intention to seek leave to appeal had been notified in December 2023. Both the application for an extension of time and the application for leave to appeal were opposed.
Applicable principles: Employment Relations Act 2000, s 214 – is it in the interests of justice to grant the extension of time sought? – are there questions of law which are of general or public importance or for any other reason ought to be submitted to the Court of Appeal for determination?
Held: The application for an extension of time is granted. The application for leave to appeal is granted.
There is a general and public importance in whether an award of damages this size was approached correctly and limited appellate authority as to the approach to awards in this context.
The questions of law to be determined in the appeal are:
(a) Did the Employment Court err in its approach to damages in light of the respondents’ pre-existing mental injury and their decision not to seek treatment when they were first diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder?
(b) Did the Employment Court err in its approach to whether superannuation losses, capital loss on the rental investment, and loss of rental payments were recoverable and as to quantum if recoverable?
EC Cronin-Lampe v Board of Trustees of Melville High School [2023] NZEmpC 221
Cronin-Lampe v Board of Turstees of Melville High School [2023] NZEmpC 144 (1)
0 Comments