Neil Sands
The Serious Fraud Office has asked the Ministry of Justice to prioritise reforms to its legislative framework after damning criticism from the Court of Appeal about the investigative body’s over-reach when issuing search warrants.
The Court of Appeal (CoA) ruled in November the SFO’s use of warrants and notices during a fraud probe into the chairman of an iwi trust, Roger Pikia, was “unnecessary, unreasonable and oppressive”.
The court noted that the SFO had gathered more than a million documents relating to Pikia’s dealings over a seven-year period, few of which were relevant to the investigation.
It said such indiscriminate use of warrants “was the antithesis of the correct approach, which requires the provision of as much specificity as is reasonably possible in the circumstances and targeting only information relevant to the frauds under investigation”.
The court said the Serious Fraud Office Act was outdated, with a notice and search framework that was no longer fit for purpose.
“The legislation is in need of urgent review. We consider that either the SFO should be brought under the SSA [Search and Surveillance Act 2012], or a new framework should be established in the SFO Act to provide the tools necessary for the SFO to function efficiently and appropriately in the contemporary digital and online environment.”
The SFO dropped the case against Pikia after Solicitor-General Una Jagose KC declined its request to appeal the CoA judgement in the Supreme Court.
New Zealand First leader Winston Peters – whose party donated were investigated by the SFO, resulting in not guilty verdicts for two people – said after the CoA judgement that the SFO was abusing its authority, as well as abusing the liberty and privacy of individuals.
“The modus operandi of the SFO to conduct unlawful fishing expeditions is now apparent and demands that the directors who have been in charge, both past and present, need to be held to account. This ruling is not a matter that can be swept under the carpet,” he said at the time.
SFO director Karen Chang told Parliament’s Justice Select Committee on Tuesday that the legislative reform demanded by the CoA was underway.
Chang said the SFO had also adjusted its processes in light of the CoA judgment.
“We have taken on board the findings of the Court of Appeal and made changes and adjustments to our processes to accommodate that, and also ensuring that with live cases and the cases that we take forward, that those findings are taken into account,” she said.
The Court of Appeal also made some comments around the reform of the Serious Fraud Office Act, which is now 35 years old and has yet to be updated.
“So, we are engaging with the Ministry of Justice, which administers our Act, on the pieces of law reform that need to be advanced, and we have urged Justice to progress them with some priority.
“But of course in the meantime, we are continuing to perform and operate with those adjustments to our internal processes under the existing laws, and our recent results show that we are doing that at pace.”
Chang said in the current financial year, the SFO had successfully prosecuted nine defendants in seven cases.
“When you look at the scale and complexity of each one of our cases, that is significant,” she said.
“So, we are both accommodating and being very alive to those [CoA] findings and making adjustments, taking action in terms of law reform, but also continuing on at pace with our work.”

0 Comments