Neil Sands
The case against Scott Watson is “overwhelming”, even without an eyewitness identification that placed him with Olivia Hope and Ben Smart on the night they were murdered in 1998, the Supreme Court was told on Wednesday.
Watson is disputing a Court of Appeal ruling last year that found there was no miscarriage of justice in allowing the identification by water-taxi operator Guy Wallace – the only person who saw the Blenheim-based pair alive before they disappeared without trace in the Marlborough Sounds in the early hours of New Year’s Day, 1998.
Watson was found guilty of their murders in 1999 and sentenced to life imprisonment, with the Court of Appeal in September 2025 dismissing a bid to overturn the double-murder conviction.
Watson’s lead counsel, Nick Chisnall KC, argued on Tuesday that Wallace’s identification in a photo line-up known as Montage B was “tainted” because police had primed him to name Watson, undermining the Crown’s entire case and resulting in a miscarriage of justice.
The Crown’s lead counsel Madeleine Laracy on Wednesday rejected the assertion.

Madeleine Laracy
“This was and remains an overwhelming case,” she said. “Mr Guy Wallace’s identification from the montage is one part of his evidence, not just one part of the totality of the evidence.”
Laracy said this had been recognised by the Court of Appeal last year, when it said that “even if one were to take out all of the montage identifications from witnesses A and B, in the court’s view it would not materially weaken the case overall”.
Wallace identified Watson as a man he saw at the bar in Furneaux Lodge, where a New Year’s party was underway, and who he later transported in his Naiad water-taxi to a boat with Hope and Smart.
‘Extraordinary coincidence’
The Crown argues that either Watson is guilty or the victim of an unlikely series of coincidences.
“If Mr Watson was not the man on the Naiad, then the lone man, like Mr Watson, just happened to be alone, happened to have a yacht, happened to have moored his yacht out from the jetty,” Laracy said.
“[He also] happened to be in the same age range, late 20s or early 30s. Happened to have an appearance which was so like Mr Watson’s as to mislead Mr Wallace into thinking it was the same man, and also happened to have the distinctive hairline that Amelia Hope [Olivia’s sister] recognised.
“The two men with these features must have been moored out alongside one another, or fairly close together.”
The Court of Appeal last year heard that two strands of Olivia Hope’s hair were found on a tiger-patterned blanket inside Watson’s boat Blade. The Court of Appeal rejected Watson’s claim the DNA evidence had been mishandled and the Supreme Court excluded it from this week’s challenge.
In submissions to the court, the Crown noted the Court of Appeal’s conclusion that the hairs had “high probative value”.
“The judge was correct to say in summing up that, if the hairs on the tiger blanket ‘did not come about accidentally, then they have strong probative force’. Contamination is ‘extremely unlikely’, and transference would be an extraordinary coincidence,” the submission says.
“The obvious explanation is that Olivia’s hairs were on Blade because she was on Blade.”
The two-day hearing is scheduled to end on Wednesday, with judgment reserved.

0 Comments