Mahvash Ikram
The Department of Corrections is inviting lawyers to participate in a survey seeking feedback about access to clients in custody after years of complaints from counsel who say contacting defendants on remand is an ongoing challenge.
Waikato-based defence lawyer Thomas Sutcliffe says the most significant issue arises when a prisoner is moved to a different facility without anybody notifying their lawyer.
“This means you may have people representing clients in the Waikato who have been moved down to Ruakākā or up to Mt Eden,” he said. Sometimes lawyers turn up to court and have to ask for an adjournment because their client has been sent somewhere else at last minute.
Criminal barrister and Vice-President of The Laws Association, Julie-Anne Kincade KC, said last minute changes to a client’s location was a significant challenge and the increase in prisoner numbers had exacerbated the problem.
But Corrections’ Commissioner Custodial Services, Leigh Marsh, said the department was seeking feedback from the profession.
“The purpose of the survey is to understand lawyers’ experiences when booking appointments with prisons, the handling of legal documentation within prisons and with arranging court instructions.”
Kincade said it was important for lawyers to complete the survey. She said Corrections was a “huge machine” and it was encouraging that it wanted to be consistent in how communications were managed in prisons across the country. “They want to cast the net as far and wide as possible and hear from practitioners as to what are the day-to-day challenges they face so they can then try and ensure that we do have communication with our clients.”
Marsh said Corrections will run another survey in mid-2026 to see if lawyers’ experiences have changed.
Creative workarounds
Sutcliffe said had been times when he was about to board a plane to meet with a client, only to discover at the last minute that the person had been moved to another facility. And there were occasions when lawyers turned up to a pre-booked online meeting only to find out their client could not join the meeting because they had been moved.
“Sometimes you don’t even know where your clients are. You have to sort of go searching through the prison system to find out which prison they’ve gone to,” he said.
“It’s not uncommon for lawyers to get a call from their client [saying] ‘hey, they’re moving me tomorrow’, and you try urgently to speak with the prison to try and stop them from moving [the prisoner], but they don’t. They put them on the bus, and they’re gone.”
Defence lawyers often resorted to creative workarounds to ensure ongoing access, Sutcliffe said. “[Lawyers] make an application to the court for an order for their client to be brought to court, simply for the purpose of getting their client to the area where they’re going to have the trial. So, they have to be moved earlier than when the prison system would [normally] move them and the courts have accommodated that.”
He said these communications breakdowns caused unnecessary delays and ultimately the taxpayer picked up the tab for inefficiencies arising out of a “third-world” system.
Sutcliffe said in-person meetings at some facilities, such as Spring Hill prison north of Hamilton, were also problematic because they were not set up to be remand facilities. “[They have] these tiny little cubicles where you have to shout in order to be heard by your client. There is no privacy. It is appalling.”
Other initiatives
Marsh said the survey was part of a wider project of improving access to prisoners in custody and Corrections has partnered with the Ministry of Justice, the judiciary and the police to set up an open prisons working group. Corrections also held regular forums with lawyers.
He said Corrections had recently provided training in prisons around the use of the online booking tool to improve record-keeping and help keep track of prisoners’ planned activities, including legal visits. “We are also working to create easier administrative processes for lawyers to gain physical access to prisons, including through the use of Authorised Provider Prison Entry ID cards,” he said.
The survey is open until 7 September.
Complete the survey here

0 Comments