One of The Law Association’s committees has criticised the “brutal” regime at New Zealand’s most secure prison unit after an official report raised concerns that it is breaching international rules on solitary confinement.
The Prisoners of Extreme Risk Unit (PERU), commonly known as “super-maxi”, was set up at Auckland Prison in 2019 to accommodate Christchurch terrorist Brenton Tarrant.
Effectively a prison-within-a-prison for inmates the Corrections Department calls the most dangerous in the system, it houses 13 prisoners.
A report by the Office of the Inspectorate, which operates independently within Corrections, found the inmates are effectively held in prolonged solitary confinement, with little meaningful human contact.
United Nations rules limit the maximum number of days in solitary confinement to 15, but the report says the average length for the 13 men in PERU is 632, and five of those have been there for more than 900 days.
It found the conditions take a toll on the prisoners’ mental wellbeing, with some saying they “felt hopeless and despondent about ever getting out of the PERU”.

Emma Priest
Barrister Emma Priest, co-convener of The Law Association’s Parole & Prisoner Rights Committee, welcomed the report, saying conditions in PERU were causing “enormous psychological harm”.
“The PERU regime is brutal,” says Priest, who represents some of the prisoners in the unit.
“The men live their lives in a nine-square-metre cell. They live in almost complete isolation.
“Most access a small yard attached to their cell with little sunlight or opportunity for meaningful physical activity. Rehabilitation services are extremely limited. Non-contact visits only are permitted.”
Changes made
In a statement endorsed by the TLA committee, Priest acknowledges there is likely to be little sympathy for the prisoners in PERU but says the authorities are obliged to uphold the law.
“The best way to test how a country adheres to human rights is to consider how they treat their weakest members,” she says.
“Corrections needs to adhere to domestic and international law. The State requires these men to abide by the law and it has a duty to do the same.”
Corrections says it has made a number of changes since the inspectorate’s visit in July last year and is committed to continuously improving operations at the unit, while ensuring safety is paramount.
While the unit houses Tarrant, the inspectorate says its report “does not, nor is it intended to, examine and report on the management of any one individual in the PERU.
“There are other complaint and review mechanisms that have proper authority and agency to address the management of individuals when they arise,” it says.
Tarrant was sentenced to life without parole in 2020 after pleading guilty to 51 counts of murder, 40 of attempted murder and one of terrorism.

0 Comments