Jenni McManus
In a nod to transparency, open justice and the rule of law, the Federal Court of Australia this week took the unusual step of posting online the statement of claim in a defamation action brought by Attorney-General Christian Porter against Australia’s national broadcaster, the ABC, and one of its journalists, Louise Milligan.
For the past two weeks Australia has been riveted, and deeply divided, by claims that Porter, at the age of 17, brutally raped a 16-year-old woman in January 1988 while both were participating in the world debating championships in Sydney.
The allegation first hit the public domain last November when friends of the woman, now deceased, tipped off Milligan, giving her a dossier of what were purported to be excerpts from the woman’s diaries. Milligan then produced a series of online articles for the ABC, claiming a senior (but unnamed) Cabinet minister was being accused of an historic rape, dating back 33 years.
Twitter and other social media platforms picked up the story and were quick to name Porter. Amid increasing pressure on Prime Minister Scott Morrison to sack his attorney-general and mount an independent inquiry, Porter outed himself on 3 March and vehemently denied the allegations. He is due to return to work on 31 March after a brief period of leave.
Morrison, meanwhile, is refusing to open another inquiry, saying the Australian Federal Police investigated the woman’s allegations when she contacted them last year. After discussions with the police, she decided not to lay a formal complaint and died by suicide in June 2020. Citing a lack of evidence, the police have declined to take the allegation any further.
Porter’s supporters – a large chunk of the Australian legal profession and the Coalition government – point to the absence of any physical evidence, witnesses or a confession, and the presumption of innocence.
Typical of their response is Chris Kenny, associate editor, national affairs at The Australian, who railed against left-wingers in Parliament and the media.
“The treatment of Attorney-General Christian Porter has not been merely trial by media but a deliberate, malicious and anti-democratic campaign by some journalists and their political comrades to destroy a politician and damage a government, regardless of the facts,” Kenny wrote.
“If the rule of law, natural justice and presumption of innocence can be disregarded in the pursuit of one Coalition minister, they can fall away for anyone. Those who have been cheering yet another savage pursuit of a conservative should pause to think; one day it could be them in the frame…
“They demand an extrajudicial inquiry because they are disappointed by the outcome of the criminal justice system. Their choice of extrajudicial process is motivated not by justice but by their desire to get Porter.”
In the other camp, friends of the dead woman, backed by members of the Australian Labor Party, the Greens and many in the media, continue to push for an inquiry. Thousands of women in Sydney, Melbourne and Canberra kept the pressure on by hitting the streets on Monday this week, reinforcing their demands for ‘justice’.
On the same day, Porter’s lawyers filed for defamation in the federal court against the ABC and Milligan, claiming aggravated damages and alleging malice. The ABC and Milligan say they will defend the action.
According to Porter’s statement of claim, Milligan “engaged in a campaign against Porter to harm his reputation and have him removed as attorney general”. Her articles were published without any attempt to give him the chance to respond and Milligan also failed to publicly disclose her close friendship with one or more of the complainant’s friends.
Porter’s lawyers also say the ABC and Milligan knew the allegations could never be proven in any criminal or civil proceeding “and despite that, had published the article to harm him and ensure he was publicly condemned and disgraced in the absence of any findings against him”.
Publishing the articles without naming the attorney-general was disingenuous, they say, “in order to give effect to their intent to harm him”. A public campaign designed to damage his reputation would be more effective against Porter than the “process of the justice system”.
Porter’s lawyers say he has been defamed, even though he isn’t named in Milligan’s most recent ABC articles – the ones claiming the police were notified that a letter had been sent to the Prime Minister, alleging an historic rape by a Cabinet minister in the federal government. It was clear that Porter was the target, the statement of claim says.
It also quotes from another Milligan article which claims Porter had “a reputation for making unwanted sexual advances” and had been accused of having “inappropriate” sexual relations with a female ministerial staffer.
In yet another article on the ABC website, Milligan claimed former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull had warned Porter about his “public behaviour” with a young female staffer. Porter says he is prepared to testify at the hearing. His lawyers say the specific defamatory inferences are that Porter was “reasonably suspected” by the police of committing the rape and that there were reasonable grounds for suspecting it had contributed to the woman’s suicide.
A statement of defence has yet to be filed.
0 Comments