Neil Sands
Former internet mogul Kim Dotcom’s long-running bid to overturn his extradition to the United States has been dismissed after the Court of Appeal rejected the argument that he faces “an effective life sentence without parole” if surrendered to the US justice system.
In a case that began when armed police raided Dotcom’s Auckland mansion in January 2012, US authorities want the German-Finnish national to stand trial of charges of criminal copyright infringement, racketeering and fraud relating to his now-defunct Megaupload empire.
He is accused of industrial-scale online piracy through Megaupload – an early form of cloud storage, which allowed users to download movies and music, allegedly costing copyright owners more than US$500 million in lost revenue and netting Megaupload more than US$175 million.
In a written judgment that followed a hearing in April, the court said it was common ground that Dotcom would face a substantially higher sentence if found guilty in the United States than he would in New Zealand.
It cited a report from US sentencing expert David Debold saying Dotcom could expect a sentence in the range of 30 to 150 years.
In contrast, two of Dotcom’s collaborators at Megaupload, Mathias Ortmann and Bram van der Kolk, received sentences of two years and seven months, and two years and six months respectively in 2023 when sentenced in New Zealand’s High Court over their involvement with Megaupload. They were released on parole after 13 months
‘Shock the conscience’
Dotcom’s lawyer, Ron Mansfield KC, told the hearing that sending his client to the United States would breach the NZ Bill of Rights protection against disproportionately severe treatment.
The relevant legal test is whether the punishment would “shock the conscience of the nation”, but the court said that in extradition matters it had to consider the sentencing regime of the country making the request, in this case the United States.
“The question is not whether the likely sentence would shock the national conscience if imposed at home, but rather whether it would shock the national conscience for a person to face such a sentence in another country after an extradition request and surrender,” it said.
It added: “The mere fact of a disparity in the length of imprisonment as between respective countries, even a very significant disparity rendering what the local court would consider a harsh sentence, is thus not in itself enough.”
‘Did not err in law or fact’
The court also dismissed Mansfield’s argument that Dotcom faced the prospect of an irreducible life sentence if extradited, noting the US system has provisions for sentence reduction on grounds such as serious health deterioration.
“We agree with the High Court that it was open to the [Justice] Minister [Paul Goldsmith] to find that Mr Dotcom was not facing an irreducible life sentence,” the three-judge panel comprising Justices Christine French, Neil Campbell and Rebecca Edwards said. “The minister did not err either in law or fact and the decision was reasonable.”
At the April hearing, Mansfield told the court that Dotcom was a 52-year-old who had recently suffered a near-fatal stroke.
Mansfield also argued that Dotcom should have been given the same chance to face New Zealand courts as Ortmann and van der Kolk, but the court said there were clear differences in their cases.
“Not only was Mr Dotcom the primary offender in terms of role and financial gain [at Megaupload], but he was also not offering to plead guilty on agreed facts, and most critically of all, the US was not prepared to withdraw its request for extradition… The US maintains its request for Mr Dotcom’s extradition to face trial in the US and is not prepared to withdraw it as it was in the case of Mr Ortmann and Mr van der Kolk.”
The court awarded costs against Dotcom for the appeal and also ordered him to pay costs plus an additional 50% for an adjournment application filed the night before the April hearing which required urgent overnight attention from Crown counsel.
Read the decision here

0 Comments