Neil Sands
The Institute of Judicial Studies has publicly released its Criminal Jury Trials Bench Book for the first time, bringing New Zealand into line with overseas jurisdictions such as the United Kingdom and Australia, where they have been available for years.
Essentially a how-to manual for judges, bench books provide non-binding guidance on topics ranging from basics such as the announcement a registrar makes at the beginning of a trial, to the nuances of dealing with vulnerable witnesses and summing-up in criminal trials.
They are prepared by judges for fellow judges to use in their day-to-day work on the bench.
But institute chair Justice Matthew Palmer said experience in other jurisdictions showed that releasing the Criminal Jury Trials Bench Book more widely would benefit the legal profession generally and help promote public understanding of court processes.
“While the bench book was written for judges, it is being released publicly with the support of Heads of Bench to promote transparency in the justice system and for educative purposes,” he said.
Elements of the bench book have been released previously in the form of question trails for juries in 2019 (now available in Chapter 5 of the bench book) and directions on sexual violence misconceptions in 2023 (Chapter 7).
But the manual has never been made public in its entirety, even though bench books are a common resource in overseas jurisdictions.
In the United Kingdom, the Judicial College’s Crown Court Bench Book has been available for at least 14 years. State jurisdictions in Australia and the United States have also published bench books, along with many Commonwealth nations.
Even Nauru, a Pacific atoll with a population of 13,000 that the New Zealand Law Society said in 2018 was “sliding into authoritarianism”, made its bench book available before Aotearoa New Zealand, publishing in September this year.
Chief Justice Dame Helen Winkelmann told LawNews in 2019 that the reluctance to publish was partly because “we haven’t had the resources to keep them up to date”.
When releasing the Criminal Jury Trials Bench Book, the Institute of Judicial Studies said further bench books would be made available.
It intends to release Te Puna Manawa Whenua – The Māori Land Court Bench Book early next year, followed later in 2025 by the Sexual Violence Trials Bench Book and Te Puna Manawa Whenua–Judging in Context: A Handbook.
Open justice
University of Auckland Associate Professor of Law Carrie Leonetti highlighted the importance of bench books last year, saying they should not be available only to judges and needed to face public scrutiny.
“They could be hopelessly outdated or full of misinformation, and there would be no way for experts, legislators, lawyers or the public to know,” she said.
Leonetti, a specialist in family violence, said she was keen to see what guidance the Family Court bench book in New Zealand provided to judges.
“I have copies of the domestic violence bench books for family courts in the United States, the UK, Canada, Australia and Commonwealth East Africa,” said Leonetti, who is on research leave and was not immediately available to LawNews for comment on this week’s release.
“But I have never seen the New Zealand domestic violence bench book. I don’t know who prepared it, what it contains or how its contents were selected.”
Leonetti said there was no compelling reason for bench books to be kept secret and their release promoted open justice.
“Judges derive their authority from democratic branches of government, so there is also a strong public interest in scholars, media and electors knowing which judges are being trained, who is providing them with the information and on what the training materials are based.”
Guidelines only
Palmer stressed that the information in the bench book is not binding.
“[It] is not intended to be a comprehensive statement of the law. It has no more authority than any other commentary. It does not bind judges and does not have the equivalent authority of a judicial decision,” he said.
“The bench book is a guide only and is one of many resources that judges may choose to refer to.”
A key element of the criminal trials bench book is Chapter 5, which contains question trails setting out 140 hypothetical fact scenarios designed to guide juries in their deliberations.
Each question trail gives a series of logically sequenced questions, written in plain English with the aim of enabling jurors to work through the elements of the charge that the Crown must prove to establish guilt.
The jury must answer each question in the affirmative before guilt is proven. The burden and standard of proof are set out at the top of all question trails.
Judges are responsible for modifying the question trails, depending on the facts of each case
The bench book says question trails for each defendant and case are primary reference materials for the jury. “The judge should draft question trails promptly once the parties’ positions are sufficiently clear and provide these to counsel,” it says.
“Question trails should be finalised with counsel in chambers before the closing addresses and distributed to the jury once general matters have been completed in the summing up.
“Best practice requires the judge to consult with counsel about the contents of the question trail before finalising its terms.”
While the directions and questions trails in the bench book are based on case law, they are suggestions for the judge to use and do not constitute the law themselves.
“The specimen directions contained in the bench book ….often need to be tailored appropriately to the facts and legal issues of the particular case,” Palmer said.
“Trial judges are free to direct the jury as they think fit, with or without reference to the bench book and provided their directions are in accordance with the law. If a trial judge does not make a direction consistent with the bench book that is not, of itself, an appealable error of law.”
The institute said the bench book will be continually updated.
“Because the bench book is updated so frequently, we recommend extracts from the bench book are only printed when required, to avoid reliance on outdated material,” it said.

0 Comments