Jenni McManus
New Zealand’s courts are moving apace towards remote hearings – at least in the civil jurisdiction – and electronic document-filing and payments are now a reality in the senior courts. But lawyers have been warned that a fully digitised court system is still a long way off.
That was one of the messages Chief Justice Dame Helen Winkelmann gave attendees at an ADLS breakfast in Auckland last week where she updated the profession on her priorities and work program for the next 12 months and beyond.
While the demands of Covid-19 had demonstrated that “real and lasting improvement in our justice system is possible” and that “achieving change does not inevitably require spending large amounts of money”, delivering justice digitally, it seems, will be expensive.
In a nutshell, “full digitisation of the courts awaits a significant investment”, Justice Winkelmann said.
But plenty had been achieved in the past 12 months to create resilience in the court system, partly in terms of collaboration and relationshipbuilding but also in the critical area of operational flexibility.
For example, digital payments and document-filing would, only 12 months ago, have seemed like a delusion, she said. This will soon be extended to the district courts. “And, no doubt, the increased use of remote hearings will become part of our business-as-usual where appropriate.”
But the Ministry of Justice is burdened with an antiquated IT system, meaning the roll-out of an electronic filing and payments system in the District Courts would not be universal, Justice Winkelmann said.
Her speech – at the first in what will become an annual ADLS breakfast event with the Chief Justice – covered four major work areas: building resilience in the justice system (which will include addressing challenges in the criminal jurisdiction), facilitating access to justice, connecting the courts to the community and ramping up the commitment to diversity within the judiciary and the profession.
Within those four areas, her theme was ‘change’ and the need for all parts of the justice system, including the profession, to work collaboratively to effect the changes needed in the court system.
“Change is not something the judiciary can achieve on its own,” she said. “It will require judiciary to work with all parts of the justice system and I see the profession as playing an absolutely critical part in that.”
‘Blow them up’
The country’s law schools came in for special scrutiny. Asked during question time how the law schools might fit into her plans, Justice Winkelmann said their approach to teaching should be ‘blown up and reconstructed’. It was the most significant structural issue the legal profession faced, she said.
“[The system] keeps children from diverse backgrounds out of the law. The figures that are coming out are shocking in terms of the prospects of someone from a low-decile school making their way through law and into the profession,” she said. “There are structural things that could be done. Because we start measuring children in our universities and law school from the moment that they enter university, they’re given no chance to adjust to learning, to equalise.
“I also have a question about whether the focus of some of the teaching is right – whether there isn’t more need for practical engagement because lawyers really are caregivers. We may not think of ourselves as that, but we surely are caregivers, especially those in the criminal jurisdiction and family jurisdiction [dealing with] people with shredded, broken lives and we need to understand the impact and the engagement of the services we provide on their lives.
“So yes, I’d blow the law schools up and redesign.” These are strongly-held beliefs: the Chief Justice in her Dame Silvia Cartwright address in October 2019 spoke of the need for diversity in the judiciary. The court system risked losing public confidence unless it reflected the communities within which judges worked, she said at the time.
The issue is still top of mind, she said last week. Between now and the end of 2026, 27 senior court appointments need to be made. During the same period, the Attorney-General will make a further 56 District Court appointments.
The judiciary is recruited from the profession which, as Justice Winkelmann said in her Cartwright address, was likely to be made up of those from the most affluent homes. Studies of intakes showed only one in 100 entrants into New Zealand’s elite universities came from the most deprived homes. Further data from six universities revealed 60% of 16,000 students accepted into law, medicine and engineering in the previous five years came from the richest one-third of homes and only 6% from the poorest. And high-decile schools received four times the number of entrylevel scholarships when compared with low-decile schools.
“Financial assistance is going overwhelmingly to students from high-decile schools.” As head of the judiciary, Justice Winkelmann said she was concerned at the implications for judicial appointments. If the law schools were overwhelmingly made up of those from the most affluent schools, then so too would be the profession from which judges are appointed.
She took up the theme again last week. “Each judicial appointment is important because judges wield public power, and the decisions they make have a profound impact on the lives they touch. “New Zealand is fortunate in its judiciary. It’s made up of people who work hard to learn about their community so they can serve it in all its diversity.
“I would like to see the appointments that are made in the next five years continuing and accelerating the work that’s already gone into building a diverse judiciary….
“I believe judicial leadership has a role to play in encouraging people from a diverse range of backgrounds and a diverse range of legal experience to see judicial appointment as a legitimate career aspiration for themselves…. We need to tell the story of diversity that already exists within our bench and also the story of what it takes to be a good judge. How intellect is important – knowledge, certainly, but so too is humility, empathy and knowledge of the community.”
The Heads of Bench have formed a committee, chaired by Chief Employment Court Judge Christina Inglis and tasked to take steps towards promoting a diversity within the judiciary.
District Court reform
Allied to the diversity issue is the change taking place in the District Court where 95% of New Zealand’s justice is dispensed.
Justice Winkelmann has publicly thrown her weight behind the work initiated by Chief District Court Judge Heemi Taumaunu last year with his Te Ao Mārama (the world of light) program which will mainstream across the entire District Court system some of the best practices of New Zealand’s 13 therapeutic courts.
These courts, including the Rangatahi courts and the Alcohol and Other Drug Treatment (AODT) courts, with their emphasis on dealing with the root causes of offending, have been centres of excellence, Justice Winkelmann said, “but the proliferation of therapeutic courts is not the answer, nor can it continue”.
The model has proved we can introduce simple practices to improve the quality of caring for those who come before the courts, both victim and offender, she said, and through those same simple processes we can improve the outcome by working to address the drivers of crime.
“But they serve only a small part of the cohort of people coming into the criminal justice system. This is literally postcode justice in operation.”
This is because those entering the court system receive inconsistent treatment based on where they are arrested. “Whilst we can tolerate that inconsistency in the short-term because it’s justified while we test and improve the model of therapeutic justice, its continuance past that therapeutic phase is fundamentally inconsistent with the rule of law.”
The Te Ao Mārama model is community-connected and will ensure the court has the information it needs to act justly, she said.
“It calls upon the community’s resources to support and rehabilitate the offender and support the victim …. It will have implications for every aspect of the criminal justice system and will even impact upon the courthouses we build.”
There is a “considerable building program” in the wings, Justice Winkelmann said, with the Ministry of Justice working with iwi “and we are reimaging courthouses as places of community justice where the community services that are needed to really address offending are given space alongside the courtroom”.
While prison incapacitated people, it did little, if anything, to address the causes of crime. It also caused intergenerational harm, with the children of prisoners seven times more likely than other children to spend time behind bars themselves. This was a conservative estimate, she said: others put the number at 10 times more likely.
“Speaking personally, I don’t see prisons being abolished because there is a legitimate incapacitation aspect to our criminal justice system, but we have to be more realistic about the impact of imprisoning people. You could ask any person in Corrections and they would accept that imprisonment makes a long-term criminal pathway more likely for many people. So, it’s something we need to have a very serious national debate about.”
Alongside the roll-out of the Te Ao Marama model, which will take some time, an extensive review is underway to simplify and improve the criminal process in the District Court.
Auckland and Manukau, in particular, are experiencing a workload crisis. The number of active jury trials has increased by 79% in the past four years – an explosion of cases that’s not related to the pandemic as numbers were ballooning long before then, though Covid-19 did make matters worse.
Justice Winkelmann said her own research suggested a number of causes for the higher rates of election, including the creation of new offences such as strangulation and money laundering.
Civil jurisdiction
In a bid to improve access to justice, the Rules Committee last year began a once-ina-generation review of the High Court Rules. This included a consultation process with the profession and the community.
Justice Winkelmann said there was a very high level of engagement and the feedback overall supported a significant change to the High Court’s presumptive procedural model.
In the District Court, serious concerns were raised about the inadequacy of judicial and registry resources in the civil justice area.
“The Chief District Court Judge and I are satisfied that this assessment in relation to the District Court is correct, having done further research, and that this is the result of the growing demand in the criminal justice jurisdiction,” she said. “Work is already underway to address a reallocation of resources.”
The Rules Committee is likely to release a further consultation document in the next quarter, setting out its recommendations.
“I expect those recommendations to be significant, both for the High Court and the District Court, and I’d like to see the profession engage with this document because I do see it as a once-in-a-generation opportunity to effect a change in the accessibility of the courts.”
In other moves, an access-to-justice committee has been formed – a joint initiative of the Chief Justice and Andrew Kibblewhite, the Secretary for Justice – with the aim of better aligning and coordinating the work of the institutions and community-led access-to-justice initiatives. It will bring together ministry representatives, the judiciary, the profession and community groups. The committee has also engaged Professor Bridgette Toy-Cronin from the University of Otago, whose research includes access-to-justice issues.
Cost is obviously one of the key barriers and here the profession must play its part, the Chief Justice said.
“If this profession is to have long-term relevance, that it’s actually serving the part of society that is not just the top end of town, then it is going to have to find a way to increase its client base to provide access to justice not just to those who can afford $350 (which is a cheap rate, I’m told) hourly rates.”
Connecting the community
An ongoing theme is to bring the communities into the courthouse.
The newly-formed Open Justice Committee, chaired by Justice Mark Cooper, is a cross-court body aimed at facilitating access to, and understanding of, the work of the courts.
To that end, the ministry has agreed to fund the introduction of live-streaming of court hearings and there will be consultation with the profession about other initiatives which may include publishing cases on appeal and the parties’ submissions to the Courts of New Zealand website to accompany live-streaming.
The Supreme Court also plans to sit occasionally in Auckland and Christchurch so the public can see the court in operation and also to create engagement with Auckland and Canterbury law schools, the Chief Justice said. The first such sitting will be in November in the Auckland High Court.

0 Comments