Neil Sands
ANZ New Zealand chief executive Antonia Watson has defended her bank’s multi-billion- dollar profits, disputing Commerce Commission findings that the banking sector is uncompetitive and lacks innovation.
Giving evidence to a select committee inquiry into banking competition, Watson acknowledged ANZ’s $2.26 billion annual net profit was “a big headline number”, but said this reflected the scale of ANZ’s operations in New Zealand.
She said a better measure of profitability was return on equity (ROE) to shareholders, which sits at about 12.3% for ANZ, which Watson said was “middle of the road for most publicly listed companies”.
“What we’ve talked about here has made it very clear that we don’t make excess profits,” Watson said.
“We’re around about our cost of capital – the minimum an investor would choose to earn to keep their money invested in us.”
A Commerce Commission report released in August found the personal banking sector operates as a “two-tier oligopoly”, allowing the big four – ANZ, BNZ, ASB and Westpac – to rake in huge profits.
In response, Finance Minister Nicola Willis described competition in the banking sector as a “cosy pillow fight” but Watson said the Commerce Commission had underestimated ANZ’s determination to gain market share
“Our staff go out every day to win over and keep customers. We back ourselves to provide the best products and services,” she said.
Watson believed the Commerce Commission used flawed methodology to conclude New Zealand has one the world’s most profitable banking sectors, saying many of the countries it used in the assessment were not comparable to Aotearoa/New Zealand.
“They’re countries that have experienced deep economic crises… Do we want to compare ourselves to countries who have experienced banking crises, whose banks are trading at below their book value?” she said.
“For us [ANZ], we’re a big importer of capital into New Zealand, which New Zealand needs to be able to grow our economy. We need to provide our shareholders with a fair return on that capital, our return on equity.
“I don’t accept us being compared to banks that trade below book value and, in some cases, make returns below New Zealand government bond rates.”
Surcharge on profits?
Finance select committee chair Stuart Smith said the Commerce Commission had “cut, sliced and diced” its data in several ways to exclude banks that had experienced issues during the Global Financial Crisis.
“So respectfully, I don’t accept that,” the National Party parliamentarian said.
Smith suggested a surcharge on bank profits, like that imposed in the United Kingdom, might be a more efficient revenue- raising measure than introducing a capital gains tax, which Watson recently supported. The ANZ chief executive disagreed.
Watson also rejected suggestions that banks’ profitability should reflect the fact that New Zealand is a relatively low-risk nation for investors.
“We’re a small country, we’re isolated from our trading partners, we’re at the bottom of the world, we’re subject to weather events, we’re subject to earthquakes, we’re a price- taker in export markets,” she said.
“I don’t agree with the risk comment. That’s reflected in our funding price. We pay more than our Australian colleagues to fund our banks because New Zealand is seen as a more risky market.”
Watson said ANZ was making progress on open banking, which gives consumers greater control of their own data, making it easier to switch financial institutions or use services such as budgeting apps and comparison tools.
But she said the introduction of open banking would be helped by the creation of an accreditation provider that would give banks confidence in the systems of the fintech companies providing the services.
“Instead of every fintech looking at each bank and having to negotiate, where we have to check their cybersecurity’s up-to-scratch, there would be a central accreditation agency in place that does that in one place and allows banks to have confidence in each of the individual fintechs,” she said.
The select committee banking inquiry is part of the coalition agreement between National and New Zealand First. It will examine issues including profitability, barriers to entry and regulatory impacts.
0 Comments