LawNews:

Enjoy access to premium content, expert analysis, and industry updates.

x

Home 5 Administrative / Public 5 Terminating Smith v Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd and its ilk: a response to The Law Association submission on the Climate Change Response (Tort Liability) Amendment Bill

Sign in below or
become a Member
to join the discussion.

Commenting Guidelines

Join the conversation by adding your comments to this story. Comments on this site are moderated before publication to encourage respectful and civil debate. By submitting your comment, you agree to our commenting rules available here.

1 Comment

  1. Warren

    This has been the central problem with Smith’s misconceived claim from the outset:

    “In contrast in Smith, while Smith chose to sue only seven parties, the logic of his claim was that prima facie every carbon and methane emitter in the country owed him a duty in tort to desist where their emissions were not net zero. If Parliament were to preserve Smith’s rights in such circumstances, would he be precluded from joining anyone other than the seven parties he had so far served, noting that the substantive proceeding had not yet got under way?”

    Aside from the slippery net zero framing of the claim (which might be repairable if he could show special damage arising from emissions exceeding that standard), it could have made for nervous dairy farmers and fossil fuel burners everywhere in NZ, had they paid the slightest attention to the case. If one adds the emissions that might subsequently be produced as a result of using the products of Smith’s defendants (seen to be relevant in a different context by a majority in Finch v Surrey County Council [2024] UKSC 20), the list of defendants would be indeterminate.

Submit a Comment

Related Content

Why criminal defendants should be granted permanent name suppression

Employment disputes split Crown Law, Solicitor-General under fire over planned reset and restructure

Commerce Commission lays down AI guidance and obligations for business

Employment Court seeks feedback on draft practice directions for non-lawyers

No results found.