Neil Sands
The University of Auckland has failed to include any practising lawyers or barristers in the committee that will review its controversial plan to merge the law and business schools.
Critics say the move freezes out those who are the most qualified to assess the proposal’s potential impact on the legal profession, with some describing it as a “stacked deck”.
The 16-person committee, listed below, is set to meet on Wednesday. Submissions on the proposal closed on January 20, following a brief consultation over the holiday period.
Chaired by the retired dean of science, Professor John Hosking, the committee comprises academics, including the deans of law at Otago University and the University of Queensland, university administrators and student representatives.
The only member from the private sector is PwC partner Paul Nickels, who leads the accountancy firm’s tertiary sector team.
Members of the legal profession have been outspoken in their opposition to the plan.

Raynor Asher KC
“It’s extremely disappointing that there are no practising lawyers or barristers on the committee and no one from the University of Canterbury, where a similar merger was ultimately reversed,” former Court of Appeal judge Raynor Asher KC told LawNews.
Clayton Kimpton, The Law Association’s chief executive, also expressed surprise at the committee’s composition.
“One of the things that was striking about the proposal from the start was that we felt it appeared to be very much an administrative review, rather than looking at what’s best for the [law] degree or the profession,” he said. “The make-up of this committee confirms those concerns.”
Kimpton questioned whether the committee had the expertise to assess broad concerns that The Law Association has raised about the proposal, including the need to train well-rounded lawyers and teach students about concepts such as access to justice and the rule of law.

Clayton Kimpton
Retired District Court judge and former Auckland Law School lecturer David Harvey said he had heard the committee described as a “stacked deck”, warning the university was leaving itself open to accusations that the outcome was preordained.
“As is so often the case with big organisations, the optics are terrible… ‘A patsy committee that gave an uncritical tick to the proposal’ will be the reaction if the merger goes through,” he told LawNews.
Harvey also questioned the expertise of committee members and repeated his call for the merger to be scrapped.
“That someone from PwC should be on [it] is curious and even more so when there is not a lawyer or KC in sight,” he said.
“I wonder at the composition of the review committee generally because there are disciplines other than law or business there and I wonder what expertise about the values that underpin legal education they bring to the table.

David Harvey
“Who knows what they are thinking, if they are thinking at all. I would have thought, given the opposition to the proposal, the university would have deep-sixed it by now.”
Faculty staff are understood to be “stunned” at the review committee’s make-up. But none would respond directly to questions from LawNews, with one hanging up after offering a terse “now’s not a good time to comment” when contacted.
Staff voiced “strong opposition” to the merger in a submission, arguing it would affect the law school’s ranking, reputation and ability to attract the best students and academics.
The merger plan – understood to be the brainchild of business school dean Susan Watson and university vice-chancellor Dawn Freshwater – was publicly released on November 12, the day after the university began its summer break.
Auckland Law School, established in 1883, is easily the country’s top-ranked, sitting at 174 on SCImago Institute’s 500-point scale of law schools, more than 100 places above its nearest New Zealand rival, Otago, at 291.
It is number 55 on the QS University World Rankings of law schools.
The review committee members are:
| Professor John Hosking (Chair) | Retired Dean, Science |
| Susan Watson | Dean, Business and Economics |
| Jaime King | Acting Dean, Law |
| Adrienne Cleland | Deputy Vice Chancellor Operations & Registrar |
| Andrew Phipps | Director, Human Resources |
| Te Kawehau Hoskins | Pro Vice-Chancellor Māori |
| Jemaima Tiatia-Siau | Pro Vice-Chancellor Pacific |
| Vandana Minhas-Tineja | Director of Faculty of Operations, Science |
| Associate Professor Jenny Malmstrom | Faculty of Engineering |
| Professor Rick Bigwood | Dean of Law, University of Queensland |
| Professor Shelley Griffiths | Dean, Faculty of Law, University of Otago |
| Paul Nickels | Partner, PwC |
| Gabriel Boyd | President, Auckland University Students’ Association (AUSA) |
| Matthew Lee | Undergraduate Education Vice-President, AUSA |
| Aurora Chen | Co-President, Auckland University Commerce Students’ Association |
| Apurva Anand | President, Auckland University Law Students’ Society |

0 Comments