Neil Sands
Taking pride of place on the wall of recently appointed Attorney-General Chris Bishop’s office in the Beehive is a framed copy of Fitzgerald v Muldoon, the landmark 1976 constitutional ruling that removes all doubt about Parliament’s role as New Zealand’s paramount law-making body.

Chris Bishop
“The judgment’s laid out word-for-word. It’s just a reminder to everyone who comes into my office about the rule of law and that Parliament is supreme,” Bishop told LawNews earlier this week, the day before Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith put the kybosh on lawsuits that attempt to hold businesses liable for climate change damage and harm from greenhouse gases.
Bishop (pictured above with incoming Solicitor-General Anna Adams KC) intends to reinforce that message following his appointment as first law officer in a Cabinet reshuffle last month.
Like his predecessor, Judith Collins KC, he has a preference for black-letter law. He’ll also be taking a similar stance to Collins when it comes to judicial appointments and the need for legislators to state their intentions clearly and precisely when drafting statutes.
“My view is that Parliament has not often been clear enough about what we’re trying to do, and intending to do, through legislation and we’ve let the courts fill in the gaps, with sometimes unpredictable consequences,” he said.
“This government, in particular, is trying to be more specific and descriptive around what exactly we are trying to do, what Parliament is trying to do.
“You can expect to see [Collins’] approach continue when it comes to judicial appointments. I’ll be following the judicial guidelines that have been in place now for a number of years. We’re looking for all the things that past attorneys have looked for, which is intellectual credibility, commitment to the rule of law and excellence, because ultimately we need smart people being judges.”
Asked about the direction he wants relationship between Parliament and the courts to take, Bishop replied: “I’ll have more to say on that soon.”
He declined to provide specifics when pressed for further details, saying only: “I’m intending to say a few things around the role of Parliament… look on the way out,” an apparent reference to his print of Fitzgerald v Muldoon.
When appointing acting judges, Bishop will follow the tightened screening process introduced by Collins in the wake of the Judge Ema Aitken comity row.
‘Don’t sleep a lot’
The Hutt South MP wears many ministerial hats in the coalition government – Housing, Infrastructure, RMA reform, Transport and Associate Finance – but says the role of the attorney-general is one of those he has coveted most since entering politics.
“New Zealand has a long history of venerable attorneys-general who are able to distinguish the party-political role from the role of the first law officer of the Crown, which is about providing frank and fearless independent advice to the government and making sure the government follows the rule of law,” he said.
“So it is a strange amalgam in that sense, but a very important one. I’m very seized by the responsibility of the role and I intend to take it seriously. One of the reasons why I always wanted to be the attorney at some point was that it brings together all of the things that I’m interested in, which is the law, politics, public policy, Parliament.”
Bishop says he is unfazed at the prospect of pulling his ministerial colleagues into line if they breach comity by criticising judges or their decisions.
“Being able to stand up to colleagues is not something I’m afraid of,” he said. “The role of a good lawyer is to provide good, impartial legal advice, and I intend to do that.
“I think it’s important that the attorney is someone quite senior in government. Obviously, Judith was a senior minister with long experience. I’m relatively high up the ranks, so hopefully that brings with it a degree of mana, dignity and gravitas to the role. It will be for others to judge whether or not that’s true, but that’s my sense of it.”
Bishop dismissed the suggestion that his slew of portfolios, which includes a once-in-a-generation overhaul of planning laws, will make it difficult to focus on the being attorney-general.
“I don’t sleep a lot as it is,” he said. “I like being busy… I get bored otherwise… I mean, there’s different ways of looking at this, but I see it as an advantage that I have a range of portfolios, because I’m sort of deeply enmeshed in a whole range of legal issues already.
“RMA reform is the classic example, where we’re repealing the RMA and replacing it. There’s a whole lot of legal complexity on the way through, so I’ve actually had quite a bit to do with Crown Law already, across fast-track, RMA reform and a range of other issues as well… so I don’t start the role as attorney with any unfamiliarity with Crown Law. I think that’s probably an advantage.”
Making the law
Bishop recently opened applications for this year’s round of King’s Counsel appointments and said he has followed the debate sparked by Lady Deborah Chambers KC about what criteria should be used when determining who takes silk.
While he agrees with Chambers that outstanding advocacy should be the main consideration, he also believes there should be flexibility to recognise achievements in other areas of the law when appointing KCs,
“I get her point. I think primarily she’s right, but there’s always going to be discretion for excellence in the law in other respects [than advocacy],” he said.
“I mean, if you take Cassie Nicholson, for example, who’s the chief parliamentary counsel [and was appointed KC last year]. I haven’t seen a lot of pushback against the idea that she’s a very worthy recipient. She’s an excellent lawyer and plays a very important role around here.”
Asked if he will become a KC like his predecessor Collins, Bishop replied: “I don’t know. It’s not my decision. It hasn’t been raised with me by anybody. Ultimately it’s not my decision.”
Bishop completed a first-class honours degree in law from Victoria University of Wellington and was admitted as a barrister and solicitor, but after completing his studies reached a crossroads which led him to choose politics over the law.
“I was all signed up to go and work with Russell McVeagh as a solicitor when a job opportunity came up in the National [Party] research unit in 2007, as I was finishing my time at law school. I had to make a choice as to whether or not I would go down the legal path or end up in politics, or at least start down that path,” he said.
“I chose joining the research unit, and then obviously, National won the 2008 election. So then I went to work for Gerry Brownlee, and then ultimately [after a two-year stint at Phillip Morris], with Stephen Joyce behind the scenes. Then I became an MP in 2014. That’s basically what happened. Russell McVeagh weren’t very happy with me, I accepted the offer, then withdrew… but these things happen.”
While he has never practised, Bishop says he has remained engaged with the legal profession during his time in politics.
“Most of my friends are lawyers around Wellington, Auckland and elsewhere. I’ve stayed in touch with the various elements of the law over the last 20 years or so, but you don’t know everyone, obviously, and not everyone knows me, so I’m intending to get out-and-about [as attorney-general] and go to some conferences, give some addresses.”
He said legal training had proved invaluable during his time as an MP, including drafting three member’s bills which have become law.
“Without a doubt, the area of law I specialised in at law school was primarily public law. My honours papers were on free speech issues, gang patch laws – ironically – and Holocaust denial laws. My honours thesis primarily specialised in public law – legislation, international law, things like that. That’s always been my great passion for the law.
“I think MPs who are lawyers end up having an attention to detail that provides an enormous amount of help in doing the job of an MP, which fundamentally is a legislative job. We are making law here.”

0 Comments