LawNews:

Enjoy access to premium content, expert analysis, and industry updates.

x

Home 5 Administrative / Public 5 National’s proposed Foodstuffs split: would a written constitution better protect property rights?

Sign in below or
become a Member
to join the discussion.

Commenting Guidelines

Join the conversation by adding your comments to this story. Comments on this site are moderated before publication to encourage respectful and civil debate. By submitting your comment, you agree to our commenting rules available here.

1 Comment

  1. Warren

    I closely paraphrase the following points on the constitutional debate in the UK, made recently by Jonathan Sumption (The Telegraph, 9 August, 20-26).

    Calling for a written constitution sounds modern, progressive, enlightened, and all the other adjectives which command instinctive support. But it is a seriously bad idea. A written constitution would have to deal with the whole workings of the state: Parliament, a possible second chamber, the powers and duties of ministers, the appointment and functions of judges, the civil service, elections, human rights, international law, and the place of the Treaty of Waitangi. It would be almost impossible to agree on them all, let alone get the result approved in a referendum.

    A written constitution would serve as a code of supreme law, overriding all other sources of law. In other words, it would contain fundamental rules which could only be altered by a constitutional amendment under some special procedure such as a referendum or a super-majority in Parliament. This necessarily involves a certain rigidity. Written constitutions are often promoted by people who want to entrench their own political values and prevent them from being abrogated or modified by a future generation which may think differently. They are designed to make major change difficult. They are powerful engines of obstruction, conservatism and immobility. And they frequently hand a blocking power to influential vested interests.

    The second way in which a written constitution would make a difference is that by formalising the rules governing the operations of the state, it would hand enormous political power to the courts. The courts would necessarily have the power to interpret those principles, and to overturn acts of Parliament, however strong the democratic mandate for them, if they did not measure up to the current crop of judges’ interpretations and leanings.

    Anyone who believes that a written constitution is a necessary protection against the despotic state should look at the world around them. The US Constitution has not stopped power from falling into the hands of a coarse and divisive megalomaniac. The constitutions of South America have not prevented the usurpation of power by military dictators. The written constitution of Russia is in part a codification of British constitutional practice, but that has not stopped the rise to power of a corrupt and predatory oligarchy.

    We can do better with what we have – it takes strong political parties that recruit talent, political will, a legislature that is sensitive to all sides of an issue, cooperation across the aisle, and able leadership.

Submit a Comment

Related Content

Why criminal defendants should be granted permanent name suppression

Employment disputes split Crown Law, Solicitor-General under fire over planned reset and restructure

Commerce Commission lays down AI guidance and obligations for business

Employment Court seeks feedback on draft practice directions for non-lawyers

No results found.